To Be Great Again: Tannenbaum Needs To Go | FinHeaven - Miami Dolphins Forums

To Be Great Again: Tannenbaum Needs To Go

FSU Truth

Toss a coin to your Witcher
☠️ Banned ☠️
Club Member
Joined
Oct 6, 2013
Messages
13,404
Reaction score
10,391
Location
Florida
This team has been marred in mediocrity or worse for over a decade. I understand this is not news to anyone and part of it is the makeup of the organization. The owner will not change and we can do little about it, but this team needs a football mind in charge to turn this organization around.

I applaud the work the “business” side of the organization with Garfinkle and everything he and his group have accomplished. The stadium looks great, the constant nods to the past, the throwback jerseys…all of it is pure class.

What lacks though is the on the field product…this team has continued to do things “half measured” since Ross became owner. These partial organizational shake-ups have done little except prevent us from luring top candidates in coaching as well as front office personnel. We fire the coach, but keep the GM and vice versa. If they are not willing to do a full on “blow this **** up” then we will continue to be mediocre or worse.

At the center of this is our, whatever his title is, Mike Tannenbaum. I’m not saying he’s awful, but what has he accomplished? Yes, he landed some big name free agents, sign some players long term, but he also did very little to fill some pretty major holes on this team. Now I will concede Hickey is to blame for this as well, but I’m already going to assume that if Philbin goes so does Hickey. What is going to be left behind is Mike T. That means we will be limited in our GM search…again, limited in our coach search….again and we will continue to wallow in this purgatory that is Dolphin football.

If we hope to actually do things right this time around then we need to drop Mike T as well, because we have the money, the facilities, and core group of player in place to recruit an excellent head coach and GM, but if left with Tannenbaum we will get second rate everything….again.
 
Well i mean Hickey was from Tampa and Bum is from the Jets IIRC. How have those franchises faired lately? Teams don't eliminate talent at any level of the franchise whether it be player, coach or management unless there is some kind of functional difference in philosophies. Miami DOES have a great history of signing players and coaches and management though from other teams discard bins. Works well, huh?
 
Unless we hire a Gruden or Cowher and they select the GM, I believe that Tannenbaum is here to stay.
If Buffett were to buy the team :up:, then all of that changes.
 
We are screwed until Ross dies or sells the team...that's it...
 
Uh, Mike Tannenbaum hasn't even gotten started. He hasn't even gotten to pick his coach yet. Ross hamstrung him with Philbin.

You want to know why the team didn't fix the O-line? Ok, I'll spell it out for you. A fixed O-line would mean this team would probably win enough games to get into the playoffs, and Philbin would probably be retained (per Ross). Everyone here including Mike T. knows that isn't good for the long-term of this franchise. The failure of this team has been ensured from the beginning.

I'm not saying Mike T. will bring in the right coach or do anything good long-term. I'm just saying 1) He didn't get to have his own coach in there yet and 2) He knows Philbin isn't the right guy, like the rest of us.
 
I agree with oasis. tbaum will have his shot to pick his guys after phailbin and coyle are gone. not saying I agree with him being the guy
 
It's wishful thinking... Tannenbaum is here to stay. Ross is slow to fire "his" guys, no matter how horrid their performance. Mr. T will run this franchise for as long as Ross continues to own the team IMO.

Ross also has a penchant for marrying together guys with different visions for the team in coaching and GMs.

Ireland should have been fired with Sparano. Didn't happen.
Philbin should have been fired with Ireland. Didn't happen.

When Philbin is fired, Tannenbaum (and even Hickey) will be retained to pair with another mediocre coach who will accept the forced marriage. That's just the way it goes in Ross world...

Sent from my Nexus 7 using Tapatalk
 
Uh, Mike Tannenbaum hasn't even gotten started. He hasn't even gotten to pick his coach yet. Ross hamstrung him with Philbin.

You want to know why the team didn't fix the O-line? Ok, I'll spell it out for you. A fixed O-line would mean this team would probably win enough games to get into the playoffs, and Philbin would probably be retained (per Ross). Everyone here including Mike T. knows that isn't good for the long-term of this franchise. The failure of this team has been ensured from the beginning.

I'm not saying Mike T. will bring in the right coach or do anything good long-term. I'm just saying 1) He didn't get to have his own coach in there yet and 2) He knows Philbin isn't the right guy, like the rest of us.

latestcb20120820220526-1.jpg
 
I really don't think that Tannenbaum was vehemently opposed to Philbin.
He was already a shadowy presence in the team before he got his official role.
So he knew Philbin well.

The only way to explain Tannenbaum "not wanting Philbin" but keeping him would be that it would allow him to have a built in buffer year.
 
I really don't think that Tannenbaum was vehemently opposed to Philbin.
He was already a shadowy presence in the team before he got his official role.
So he knew Philbin well.

The only way to explain Tannenbaum "not wanting Philbin" but keeping him would be that it would allow him to have a built in buffer year.

I don't think it takes that smart of a guy to be aware of Philbin's shortcomings as a HC. Ross acted in bizarro, impulsive fashion to retain Philbin. I bet Tannenbaum felt like, "Hey Steve, we weren't even going to talk about this??" Very plausible that Tannenbaum considered it a foregone conclusion they would evaluate (and ****can) the coaching staff after the season. Meanwhile Ross sees a "gutsy" win against a terrible Vikings team and convinces himself during that wave of pride that he indeed already has the coach to lead the Phins to glory.

Mike T has been given full control, but on that move Ross completely undermined him and swept the rug out from under him.
 
He isn't going anywhere, and we're gonna have Eric Mangini shoved up our ass next year. Ross gonna Ross.

---------- Post added at 12:21 PM ---------- Previous post was at 12:20 PM ----------

2af8a3b69468b118fb87cece81e47365-1.jpg
Ross just infuriates me. He has no damn clue how the NFL works.


---------- Post added at 12:22 PM ---------- Previous post was at 12:21 PM ----------

Not antsy enough I guess, eh Steve?
 
This is what worries me...

If Tannenbaum already has a guy in mind or a coach in mind..then that is who we get...

Top GM candidates are not going to want to be in Miami with this guy looking over their shoulder
 
Back
Top Bottom