PhinBeck
Perennial All-Pro
- Joined
- Apr 19, 2003
- Messages
- 4,863
- Reaction score
- 0
Noland said:No he might have went a little to far. But people on this site kiss Feeley's tail saying that he is going to be this or that when a month ago it was cut his dumba** threads. He may have quit making stupid mistakes. But his #'s aint no different than aweful Fiedlers. Fiedler made mistakes here and there but his biggest problem was not having big games on consistent bases. I think It is way to early to say he is the answer. I'm sorry he has made some good throws but I still have questions.
Ok this is what makes me peeved. Stats - stop using them as your argument. What did Jay do THIS YEAR w/o a run game? Nothing, with more experience and teh players pulling for him. Plus the one thing jay has that AJ doesnt is mobility. AJ is getting killed, sorry but it is a lie to say teh o-line played well Sunday, they didnt. He has teh physical tools, is showing development mentally. Noone is guarenteeing anything, they are saying they feel he will be good based on what they have seen, there is a diff. Bashers are guarenteeing failure by stating his demise as fact. AJ deserves a shot behind a solid o-line, and a ground game behind him. That isnt saying we shouldnt get anyone else. But anyone that says this season is a fair indication of how well AJ may do is fooling themselves and are biased against him. Using journalists and non sports journalists at that as a abasis for an opinion is ridiculous. I take Kosars opinion on a qb nefore Tom Arnold's, at least kosar has a foundation from which to judge.