Tom Donahue's Analysis Of Draft's Top Ol | FinHeaven - Miami Dolphins Forums

Tom Donahue's Analysis Of Draft's Top Ol

dougfinsfan72

Practice Squad
Joined
Apr 13, 2005
Messages
373
Reaction score
0
Location
Fort Lauderdale, FL
Surprisingly, he makes no mention of UGOH!!! NONE!!!
He speaks highly of Levi Brown!!

Good year for left tackles
Thomas leads the way
By Vic Ketchman, jaguars.com senior editor
03/20/07

clear.gif

Jaguars.com previews the 2007 NFL draft in an eight-part series. Part IV features the offensive linemen.


This is a great year to need a left tackle. Wisconsin’s Joe Thomas (pictured) tops a left tackle crop that’ll go deep into the first day of the draft.
“The interesting thing about my tackles is they’re all left tackles. You hope it’s that way but that’s rare,†former Bills president and Steelers director of football operations Tom Donahoe said. Donahoe previews this year’s crop of offensive linemen in a guest appearance as jaguars.com’s talent evaluator.
Here’s Donahoe’s top 10 offensive linemen:

1. Joe Thomas, T, 6-6, 311, Wisconsinâ€â€Thomas is an accomplished left tackle who overcame a knee injury and subsequent surgery in his junior season. Thomas struggled early last season and was tentative in his play, but returned to his old self late in the year. He’s athletic and intelligent; a top pass-blocker who may not be totally recovered from the knee injury but far enough back to be a top five pick. Thomas has room to grow and add more power to his frame.

2. Levi Brown, T, 6-5, 323, Penn Stateâ€â€Brown offers power as a run-blocker to the left tackle position. He needs to improve his pass-blocking but he’s athletic enough to leave no doubt he will. When he does, he could become a dominant player. As it stands, he’s a little vulnerable at times to an inside move. “He has more bulk than some of these other tackles and has more power in his game. He didn’t run as well at the combine but he can bend his knees and slide his feet,†Donahoe said of Brown. Brown figures to be a top 10 pick.

3. Joe Staley, T, 6-6, 306, Central Michiganâ€â€If you want a pure athlete, Staley is your guy. He ran a 4.75 at the combine and is a pure left tackle. “A little under the radar because of where he played, but when you look at his game and his athletic ability, he has a chance to be drafted pretty good,†Donahoe said. Staley needs to get a little stronger. He’s a late-first round prospect.

4. Ben Grubbs, G, 6-2, 311, Auburnâ€â€Grubbs is tough physically and mentally. He’s already graduated; team leader with good feet and the power to play inside. “If he has a weakness, it’s in pass-protection but I don’t think it’s a major flaw,†Donahoe said. Grubbs will go late in round one or early in round two.

5. Aaron Sears, G/T, 6-3, 319, Tennesseeâ€â€Sears is a tackle who will probably move to guard. He’s played all the line positions except center; very versatile, very strong, very tough and a three-year starter. He can play in space. Second round.

6. Justin Blalock, G/T, 6-3, 320, Texasâ€â€Played guard and tackle; more of a right tackle than a left. Four-year starter who is a good run-blocker. Has some power in his game, but needs to be more consistent and play with more intensity. Second round.

7. Ryan Kalil, C, 6-2, 299, USCâ€â€Ã¢â‚¬Å“I love this player. I think he’s a little bit of a throwback. Some people are worried about his size but I think he’s one of the toughest linemen in the draft,†Donahoe said. Kalil has good bloodlines; father played in the USFL. “He reminds me of Tom Nalen,†Donahoe added. Second or third round.

8. Doug Free, T, 6-6, 324, Northern Illinoisâ€â€He may need time; he’s raw but a good long-range prospect. Big, rangy; needs to get stronger and improve his technique. Free offers major upside for the third round.

9. Ryan Harris, LT, 6-4, 305, Notre Dameâ€â€Very athletic but is a finesse player and has to develop more strength and power in his game. Too good of an athlete not to be taken on the first day. Three-year starter, very smart but needs more anchor and power in his game. Harris’ stock fell at the Senior Bowl.

10. Manny Ramirez, G, 6-3, 326, Texas Techâ€â€Ramirez is a classic road-grader. “He’s a short-area player; a mauler who benches 550 pounds. Ramirez has a good work ethic but he’s got to be the right fit for somebody; somebody who zone-blcks and doesn’t want their guards out in space,†Donahoe said. Fourth round.

Other tackle prospects include James Martin of Boston College and Mike Otto of Purdue. Donahoe is high on guards Andy Alleman of Akron, Allen Barbre of Missouri Southern and Cameron Stephenson of Rutgers. Leroy Harris of North Carolina State and Doug Datish of Ohio State are centers who will be drafted.
 
I feel pretty good about the Dolphins drafting Levi Brown if they stay at #9... I think as a tackle he might be signed and in camp on time...but then again who knows?
 
Looks like we can wait until the 2nd or even the 3rd to pick up very good OL help. I thought Kalil would have been more highly regarded. I would fall out of my chair if we were able to pick him up with our 2nd pick in the 2nd. I'm still am not sold on Levi being a great LT due to quickness issues, but that's why these pro's make the big bucks.
 
It's a very mistake ridden analysis. Staley for example, pulled a muscle and didn't run in Indy. And the 4.75 was from the CMU Pro Day of 2006.

Very poor.
 
Adam Koets is a name to watch with regards Miami. There is strong interest there.
 
Allen Barbre?

Adam Koets is a name to watch with regards Miami. There is strong interest there.

Boomer (or anyone),
Do you have any info on Allen Barbre of Missouri Southern? There was no way for me to see any game film him, and reports are limited.

What I do know:
-He's 6-4 and 305
-He was one of the best athletes at the combine on the OL beating almost everyone in speed (4.84/40, 4.63/20 yrd shuttle) and matching the 28 reps that Joe Thomas threw up
-Even at his size, he was so quick his college coach put him in on punt returns ...Here's what Southern Missouri’s offensive line coach Casey Meile's had to say about him in a recent article in The Joplin Globe: "Considering he's the first guy down on the punt team every time, Allen is a special athlete," he said.

Could he be one of those late-round projects that Cam and Hudson like to work with?
 
Surprisingly, he makes no mention of UGOH!!! NONE!!!
He speaks highly of Levi Brown!!

Good year for left tackles
Thomas leads the way
By Vic Ketchman, jaguars.com senior editor
03/20/07

http://www.jaguars.com/story/images/240x180/story(5904)240x180.jpg
Jaguars.com previews the 2007 NFL draft in an eight-part series. Part IV features the offensive linemen.


This is a great year to need a left tackle. Wisconsin’s Joe Thomas (pictured) tops a left tackle crop that’ll go deep into the first day of the draft.
“The interesting thing about my tackles is they’re all left tackles. You hope it’s that way but that’s rare,†former Bills president and Steelers director of football operations Tom Donahoe said. Donahoe previews this year’s crop of offensive linemen in a guest appearance as jaguars.com’s talent evaluator.
Here’s Donahoe’s top 10 offensive linemen:

1. Joe Thomas, T, 6-6, 311, Wisconsinâ€â€Thomas is an accomplished left tackle who overcame a knee injury and subsequent surgery in his junior season. Thomas struggled early last season and was tentative in his play, but returned to his old self late in the year. He’s athletic and intelligent; a top pass-blocker who may not be totally recovered from the knee injury but far enough back to be a top five pick. Thomas has room to grow and add more power to his frame.

2. Levi Brown, T, 6-5, 323, Penn Stateâ€â€Brown offers power as a run-blocker to the left tackle position. He needs to improve his pass-blocking but he’s athletic enough to leave no doubt he will. When he does, he could become a dominant player. As it stands, he’s a little vulnerable at times to an inside move. “He has more bulk than some of these other tackles and has more power in his game. He didn’t run as well at the combine but he can bend his knees and slide his feet,†Donahoe said of Brown. Brown figures to be a top 10 pick.

3. Joe Staley, T, 6-6, 306, Central Michiganâ€â€If you want a pure athlete, Staley is your guy. He ran a 4.75 at the combine and is a pure left tackle. “A little under the radar because of where he played, but when you look at his game and his athletic ability, he has a chance to be drafted pretty good,†Donahoe said. Staley needs to get a little stronger. He’s a late-first round prospect.

4. Ben Grubbs, G, 6-2, 311, Auburnâ€â€Grubbs is tough physically and mentally. He’s already graduated; team leader with good feet and the power to play inside. “If he has a weakness, it’s in pass-protection but I don’t think it’s a major flaw,†Donahoe said. Grubbs will go late in round one or early in round two.

5. Aaron Sears, G/T, 6-3, 319, Tennesseeâ€â€Sears is a tackle who will probably move to guard. He’s played all the line positions except center; very versatile, very strong, very tough and a three-year starter. He can play in space. Second round.

6. Justin Blalock, G/T, 6-3, 320, Texasâ€â€Played guard and tackle; more of a right tackle than a left. Four-year starter who is a good run-blocker. Has some power in his game, but needs to be more consistent and play with more intensity. Second round.

7. Ryan Kalil, C, 6-2, 299, USCâ€â€Ã¢â‚¬Å“I love this player. I think he’s a little bit of a throwback. Some people are worried about his size but I think he’s one of the toughest linemen in the draft,†Donahoe said. Kalil has good bloodlines; father played in the USFL. “He reminds me of Tom Nalen,†Donahoe added. Second or third round.

8. Doug Free, T, 6-6, 324, Northern Illinoisâ€â€He may need time; he’s raw but a good long-range prospect. Big, rangy; needs to get stronger and improve his technique. Free offers major upside for the third round.

9. Ryan Harris, LT, 6-4, 305, Notre Dameâ€â€Very athletic but is a finesse player and has to develop more strength and power in his game. Too good of an athlete not to be taken on the first day. Three-year starter, very smart but needs more anchor and power in his game. Harris’ stock fell at the Senior Bowl.

10. Manny Ramirez, G, 6-3, 326, Texas Techâ€â€Ramirez is a classic road-grader. “He’s a short-area player; a mauler who benches 550 pounds. Ramirez has a good work ethic but he’s got to be the right fit for somebody; somebody who zone-blocks and doesn’t want their guards out in space,†Donahoe said. Fourth round.

Other tackle prospects include James Martin of Boston College and Mike Otto of Purdue. Donahoe is high on guards Andy Alleman of Akron, Allen Barbre of Missouri Southern and Cameron Stephenson of Rutgers. Leroy Harris of North Carolina State and Doug Datish of Ohio State are centers who will be drafted.

Barbre is a LT and would fit the bill nicely for us if we miss one of the other "premier" LT's in the draft. See my mock below.
 
Boomer (or anyone),
Do you have any info on Allen Barbre of Missouri Southern? There was no way for me to see any game film him, and reports are limited.

What I do know:
-He's 6-4 and 305
-He was one of the best athletes at the combine on the OL beating almost everyone in speed (4.84/40, 4.63/20 yrd shuttle) and matching the 28 reps that Joe Thomas threw up
-Even at his size, he was so quick his college coach put him in on punt returns ...Here's what Southern Missouri’s offensive line coach Casey Meile's had to say about him in a recent article in The Joplin Globe: "Considering he's the first guy down on the punt team every time, Allen is a special athlete," he said.

Could he be one of those late-round projects that Cam and Hudson like to work with?

184. (6th) Allen Barbre, OT, Missouri Southern 6’4, 300, 4.84/40 – Another late round steal with great speed. He has the second fastest 40 time of any of the 36 OT’s rated on foxsports.com behind only you know who, Joe Staley. Check out the link on him and see for yourself what a stud this guy is. He’s good enough that we could probably forego a LT pick at 9and go with Laron Landry or whoever was the BPA on the board. But, with the Phins so weak on OL depth, both Barbre and Staley at 9 would be just what the doctor ordered. A team can never have enough depth.
 
I can't see Kalil falling to the 3rd round...no way no how....Blaylock could be there in round 2 but he won't be there for very long....I still think we'll take a guard or a center in round 2 and I don't believe we'll take Brown at 9.

Ozzy rules!!
 
Boomer?

Is there any truth to the lack of interest by Miami in Brown? I am not sure I believe that. However, Mueller is known to be weary of drafting lineman high. It would make sense to me that he target guys in the late 2nd (60) and third round. If you were guessing, what three lineman would you draft if you knew that was the number Miami would sign?

Lee2000
 
Is there any truth to the lack of interest by Miami in Brown? I am not sure I believe that. However, Mueller is known to be weary of drafting lineman high. It would make sense to me that he target guys in the late 2nd (60) and third round. If you were guessing, what three lineman would you draft if you knew that was the number Miami would sign?

Lee2000


Lee,

They interviewed Levi in Mobile and they used one of their 60 allotted interviews in Indianapolis on him.

I'd say that there's a strong interest. But there's no use in letting the whole football world know. It may be that they're playing up their interest in Staley.
 
Back
Top Bottom