I really debated adding the Marino to Fryar play- my top 4 I am sold on because they are all playoff games and more meaningful games. So I debated the Patriots game vs the Jets game, essentially for the #5 spot. It really could have gone either way, but the NYJ game was on the road and we started that comeback down 18. I just thought it had more weight factoring in those two things. For that reason I tossed in the Patriots play as an HM....it had to get some love.
I am unfortunately a smidge too young (HA!) to remember the Dick Anderson play, though I have seen it and it looks incredible.
As one poster astutely noticed, the most recent of these plays is almost 17 years ago- it's been a long time since we've really been a contender. I just wanted to go back and re-live some glory moments.