Travis Henry for Ricky Williams? | Page 4 | FinHeaven - Miami Dolphins Forums

Travis Henry for Ricky Williams?

FinsFan74 said:
There are rumblings that Buffalo will eventually have to deal with the situation of Travis Henry wanting out (because McGahee will start ahead of him)......what do you all think about trading him for Ricky Williams straight up....I know one thing, the Bills-Fins games would sell out!!
Click to expand...


Why would the Jills want to trade one problem for another ?? Why would Henry want to come to the Fins with such a crowded backfield ?? This idea does not bring any value to either team. Ricky has NO trade value to anyone right now...the Jills would be laughed out of the next NFL meetings (whenever they are)...they would instantly become the "laughing stock" of the NFL. Donahoe has much more sense than to make a move like that...A move like that, at this time, benefits the Fins much more than the Jills and provides nothing of what Henry wants....IF Wacky is to have ANY value to the Fins (via trade or as a RB), he must return this season and prove he can get his act together and stay clean...then MAYBE we could get some return trade value next offseason...
 
F150&Dolfan said:
No Way Jose. Like him or not a motivated Ricky Williams is better than Henry or McGahee and although he hasn't taken a carry in the NFL yet I'd say he's better than Ronnie Brown also.
Click to expand...

i agree with you also. why would you want to trade a probowl back for Henry! Henry! he couldn't hold rickys jock....
 
Boik14 said:
Rw>Henry.

RW's Contract > the new one that henry wants

Rw doesnt complain about being a backup/sharing time (or at least hasnt publicly) > Henry's whining.

That about sums it up folks. Henry's good, Rw's better. No one ever talked about Henry as a top 3 or even top 5 RB. He never will be. RW was and while thats no guarantee he will be there again, his potential > Henry's.
Click to expand...

Rickys potential for being a total failure is MUCH greater than Henry's. Ricky has stated he only wants to play 2 more years, and has proven that he could quit at any moment regardless of the implications for his team. The Bills would NEVER give up a valuable backup/potential starter for such a high risk.
 
FinsFan74 said:
There are rumblings that Buffalo will eventually have to deal with the situation of Travis Henry wanting out (because McGahee will start ahead of him)......what do you all think about trading him for Ricky Williams straight up....I know one thing, the Bills-Fins games would sell out!!
Click to expand...


bills-fins games for the most part already do sell-out
 
FinsFan74 said:
There are rumblings that Buffalo will eventually have to deal with the situation of Travis Henry wanting out (because McGahee will start ahead of him)......what do you all think about trading him for Ricky Williams straight up....I know one thing, the Bills-Fins games would sell out!!
Click to expand...

The Fins-Bills game will sell out anyway.....horrible trade.
 
Right now, I'd trade Ricky for a Billy the Big-Mouthed Bass singing Bass. He comes loaded with two different songs.

Amusing for parties, birthdays and funerals, on so many levels!
 
i'd rather have ricky be our #2 rb for 3 years than trade him to the Bills...for Henry...and like others have said...this would be a really stupid trade. RW is much better than Henry...RW...if he gets his head on straight (that's a BIG IF) IMO is even better than McGahee. So why the hell would we want to do that?

Stupid trade...period.

Go Fins!!!
 
5P1KES said:
I'll bet you all that Ricky Williams will never be the same running back prior to choosing the reefer over the pigskin.
Click to expand...

Why?????? Do you honestly think there was ever a time while Ricky was not smoking pot??????? I'm willing to bet he's been a refer smoker through his whole college and pre career including his 2002 season. Marijuana is the most overblown drug in the world. Alcohol will ruin a person's career much faster than smoking pot will.
 
MDFinFan06 said:
wow man im sorry but i dont have much faith in ricky anymore and although i do hope he becomes what he was i seriously doubt that and i would say as of now he WAS better than any of those backs, not now. I believe, and hope, that Ronnie will make Ricky look like as joke and someone we can forget.:eek:
Click to expand...

The key word to my post in MOTIVATED, don't forget that. I never said he will definitly be motivated but if he is he's a top 3 back.
 
PHINZONER said:
Willis missed a year and played awsome last year! What are you smoking to assume that possibly the best college rb ever and a NFL ELITE rb (w/proven talent to be the top in the NFL)can not regain his form!

Why would you trade that for Henry, to a division rival? So the Bills could run wild on the FINS!!!! Willis and Ricky would post 100yd games!! No way!!!!!!!
Click to expand...

Can't dispute that however call me when he gains 1850 yards in the NFL and averages 4.8 YPC. At that point I'll give him the nod. IMHO it only matters what a player does in the pros. I don't give a rats *** about what they've done in college.
 
There's no way they'll trade Ricky to an AFC East team. They wouldn't trade Williams for Henry under any circumstances anyway. Nothing good can come of that.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Back
Top Bottom