Tua vs. Herbert

[eMCee85]

Its being discussed in multiple other threads so...

Tua = 1,214 yds, 9 TDs, 1 INT, 57.3 QBR

Herbert = 3,467 yds, 25 TDs, 10 INT, 66.5 QBR

These numbers are per ESPN.

Situations are different... obviously yes.

I am glad we got Tua and support him because he's a phin and I love our phins but man seeing Herbert sling the rock like he does, I admit, it does have me thinking. My reason for picking Herbert over Tua is the hip. I seriously worry every game about it. I dont like picking injured players. He's smart as **** though and hopefully the gamble pays off in the end.

So who made the better pick, Chargers or Dolphins?

 

[elite14eva]

We also don't have the weapons that Herbert has

 

['Deep]

Do we really need to go here?

 

[circumstances]

Let's revisit when there is enough information to render a decision.

Two or three years from now.

 

[eMCee85]

Let's revisit when there is enough information to render a decision.

Two or three years from now.

True, but what if Tua doesn't make it that long?

 

[fishfanmiami]

Its being discussed in multiple other threads so...
So who made the better pick, Chargers or Dolphins?

Dolphins

More upside when he gets some weapons

 

[AllFinsAllDay]

I think Tua is the better. Herbert has played more games and has way better weapons right now than Tua does.

You switch the players and I bet Tua puts up the same numbers with LA.

 

[EasyRider]

Who made the better pick?
good god, dumb question.
This can’t be real

 

[EasyRider]

I’ll play along
the Bengals

 

[DolfanISS]

True, but what if Tua doesn't make it that long?

What if Herbert doesn’t?

 

[gregorygrant83]

Lets see where they're at after each has attempted 500 passes. I would guess Herbert will have thbe edge yardage wise and Tua will have thrown fewer ints. It looks like both will be good qbs. In a few years you could have Burrow, Tua, Herbert, Mahomes , Jackson Watson, Lawrence and Mayfield as young qbs in the AFC. It's possible some teams are going to have pretty good qbs and still not have a top 10 qb.

 

[DolfanISS]

This question won’t be answered for years.

The real question is if Tua ends up being better how many Finheaven posters will be disappointed? Sure seems like some are married to their “should have drafted Herbert” take.

 

[Michael Morris]

He's got Mike Williams, Keenan Allen, and a much better running game. In the end, I think both qb's are going to be really good. This year is like 1983 you couldn't go wrong with any one of these top qb's.

 

[Fred Bear]

I'm happy with our quarterback the quarterback of the Miami Dolphins

 

[eMCee85]

This question won’t be answered for years.

The real question is if Tua ends up being better how many Finheaven posters will be disappointed? Sure seems like some are married to their “should have drafted Herbert” take.

Its true on both sides. It seems there's no middle on these two qbs on this thread. Me, I like both qbs. Wouldn't it be awesome if they both turned out to be great qbs and it was like a Marino vs. Kelly almost every year. I would love that