Tyreek or Deebo/Kadarius | FinHeaven - Miami Dolphins Forums

Tyreek or Deebo/Kadarius

M

madridfinfan

Rookie
Joined
Apr 26, 2007
Messages
557
Reaction score
505
Just for fun. Now that Deebo and Kadarius seem to be available, in retrospect, what combo would you have preferred? The Deebo/Kadarius combo probably would have cost, salary wise, and draft pick compensation, about the same I would have imagined, perhaps even less picks would have been involved than we gave up for Tyreek.

If all 3 were on the table a month ago, which way are you going?
 
From a pure talent and impact stance, Hill without a doubt. You can make cases for Samuel, Toney or even Laviska Shenault in Jacksonville. In terms of lower cost and age (Shenault and Toney) or familarity with scheme (Samuel). Don't underestimate the value of the impact trading for Hill has as far as sending a message to Tua, the rest of the team and the entire league.
 
gregorygrant83 said:
From a pure talent and impact stance, Hill without a doubt. You can make cases for Samuel, Toney or even Laviska Shenault in Jacksonville. In terms of lower cost and age (Shenault and Toney) or familarity with scheme (Samuel). Don't underestimate the value of the impact trading for Hill has as far as sending a message to Tua, the rest of the team and the entire league.
Click to expand...
Well put and agree on all fronts. This FO is all behind Tua. Time for Tua to focus l. What’s important, without distractions and full sport, and silence the critics.
 
Out of the 3, Hill, but to me Toney is still on our radar because he can be had for way less than Deebo in a trade, and he would still be on his rookie deal. No brainer if we can still get him.
 
I'd have preferred Deebo/Kadarius due to age, and Deebo's experience in the system. That ship has sailed though, and Grier couldn't have known that Kadarius would be available. We still don't know if the Niners are even willing to trade Deebo.
 
Hill is the most dangerous wideout in the league. If you have a young qb and want to help him as much as possible then Hill is your guy. You can teach a wideout to catch, to run routes but you can not reach speed. Defenses will have to devote 2-3 guys to contain Hills speed. Even the most elite wideouts in the league there’s corners like Ramsey and Howard that you’ll probably leave them on an island vs the wideout. With hill there’s not a single corner that can single cover him. You’re either single covering playing 10-12 yard off and he’s going to eat underneath or you’re asking for safety help. This will open up the run game and for waddle,Wilson or gesicki to eat short,middle or deep on the opposite side if only single high.
 
Toney seems to have behavioural issues and injury issues. Deebo would be similar in price but less of a great player than Hill.
 
Hill and it’s not even close. Deebo is a nice talent but he hasn’t shown it over a long period of time like Hill has. The fact Toney is on the trading block after just one season in the league has to be a big warning sign for any team thinking about trading for him.

Personally I have zero interest in Toney and he isn’t even close to the player Hill and Deebo are. It won’t surprise me if he doesn’t end up being a complete bust because of his immaturity.
 
Toney is a nutcase. Even my Gator homer friend wanted no part of him. He'll be really good his contract year and that's basically it.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Back
Top Bottom