UPDATE: The Vilification of the '72 Dolphins | FinHeaven - Miami Dolphins Forums

UPDATE: The Vilification of the '72 Dolphins

Fin D

Cletus Disco
☠️ Banned ☠️
Joined
Apr 9, 2005
Messages
1,714
Reaction score
1,393
Age
50
Location
Florida
I posted this yesterday:

Finascious D said:
I was reading Peter King's MMQB today, and came across this:



"
The Colts' loss to San Diego ended at 4:21 p.m. EST. By 6:07, quotes from seven 1972 Dolphins players, plus coach Don Shula, were in my e-mail, from the Miami PR staff. Efficient, to be sure. But does that team have to be so publicly joyful EVERY time the last unbeaten team loses a game, keeping the legacy of the only unbeaten NFL team ever intact?"

So I sent this letter in, I doubt it'll be in the MMQB Tuesday addition, but you never know.



I read your column every week, its one of my favorites, however, I take exception to the vilification of the '72 Dolphins. The argument states that they celebrate other people's misfortunes, with a champagne toast when the last undefeated team falls. How is this really different then a fan celebrating a win of one team over another. In a win, there was one team who was unfortunate. Is the fan celebrating the losing team’s failure? Is that a lack of class? What if the fan, actually had something to lose, like a wager or even bragging rights? Those Dolphins achieved something no other has, if someone else does it they'll congratulate them, but if no one else accomplishes it, then they should cherish it. In this age of Terrell Owens and his ilk, when you yourself look to teams like the Patriots as the embodiment of team accomplishment, why is it so wrong for a team to celebrate the ultimate team accomplishment? They aren’t out there celebrating individual achievements. Thank you.

So in case anyone cares...

I just read the the Tuesday Edition of MMQB, and there was...drum roll please...NO RESPONSE!

Take it for what you will, but I choose to see it as victory. Mr. King couldn't argue with it, so he chose not to!;)
 
the dolphins have become this country's public enemy #1 because of the 72' season which i think our guys deserve some respect.
 
I have no problem with them celebrating it, but they set themselves up for vilification by publicizing it so much. Every radio show yesterday had Shula or Kiick or whoever and in King's column he starts by saying how he got e-mailed quotes from 7 players plus Shula just hours after the game. He didn't seek them out, they were sent to him. It's fine to celebrate quietly amongst yourselves. Hell, it's fine to publicly brag and slap each other on the back in the public square, but then don't whine about the reaction. You can't have it both ways.
 
islandah said:
I have no problem with them celebrating it, but they set themselves up for vilification by publicizing it so much. Every radio show yesterday had Shula or Kiick or whoever and in King's column he starts by saying how he got e-mailed quotes from 7 players plus Shula just hours after the game. He didn't seek them out, they were sent to him. It's fine to celebrate quietly amongst yourselves. Hell, it's fine to publicly brag and slap each other on the back in the public square, but then don't whine about the reaction. You can't have it both ways.

Before King recieved those emails, there was already bs beginning in the media, about the "champagne toast". I just don't see what's so wrong about it. This year is the first time I remember people griping about it. Is it wrong for a an ex-Hurricane to publicly celebrate a win by their alma-mater?

Not to mention, the media is making the celebration public, and then blasting the old teammates. That's hypocrisy.
 
Peter King, you just got...

clear.gif
 
The one thing King missed is that Shula and the 72 team's phones start ringing before the clock even gets to :00 in the Colts game. The media jumps on the team to get reactions and quotes. It's not like Shula held a press conference right after the Colts lost. If anyone wants to make an issue out of the 72 team they need to start with being mad at the media.

Until another team goes undefeated then the Dolphins have every right to celebrate one of the truly outstanding feats in sports history.

Bottom line is all the other fans are jealous.

Oh, and if King still thinks the Patriots are the "class of the NFL" then he hasn't watched that team very close.
 
Finascious D said:
Before King recieved those emails, there was already bs beginning in the media, about the "champagne toast". I just don't see what's so wrong about it. This year is the first time I remember people griping about it. Is it wrong for a an ex-Hurricane to publicly celebrate a win by their alma-mater?

Not to mention, the media is making the celebration public, and then blasting the old teammates. That's hypocrisy.
Exactly. That annual toast is a private party in case they were wondering.
 
Let's see.. it's wrong to celebrate and hold sacred the single most amazing accomplishment in team sports history?? Gotch ya, Peter. BTW, for anyone that cares, I listen to PK every week on buffalo radio pandering to that pathetic franchise. He's always got a comment about the fins. It may just be him preaching to his choir (John Clayon is even worse). But King's a hack, IMO
 
Back
Top Bottom