Very uncool QB situation ... | Page 2 | FinHeaven - Miami Dolphins Forums

Very uncool QB situation ...

With the uncool QB situation, what should our FO do?

  • Total voters
    134
Slim said:
Why is Tebow and option in this poll???? Denver just used a 1st rounder for him and fans see him as the second coming of Christ.
Click to expand...
John Elway stated last month he doesn't see a true franchise passer on his roster, so:

- They can trade anyone, as current FO took command at the middle of last season so none of their passers was selected for them.
- They might argue Kyle Orton & Brady Quinn have shown the required level to compete for starting role at any place in the league.

Also I'm assuming a Moore for Tebow + 2nd round could be fair, allowing them to keep Orton & Quinn.
 
Vaark said:
Giving a 2nd plus a first string DL for a mediocre QB with a 60.8QBR on 3rd downs and a -7 loss record over the the past 2 years is insanity. Of thos options, I'm holding out hope for Carson Palmer so that explains my "other" vote. Otherwise I'd go with Henne or whomever might unseat him since I don't see an upside between 5 and 8 wins next season with or without Orton... only a downside.
Click to expand...
So let's say you're sticking with Henne as Palmer seems leaded to retire.
 
FinsFan74 said:
Last time I looked, several fans don't make the decisions for the front office let alone constitute the majority of the fan base. If fans ran the show we may actually have a team that makes a run at the Super Bowl
Click to expand...
Or could have a lot of fancy faces without future draft picks after a bunch of trades and poor equanimity to execute well.
 
MexDolfan said:
John Elway stated last month he doesn't see a true franchise passer on his roster, so:

- They can trade anyone, as current FO took command at the middle of last season so none of their passers was selected for them.
- They might argue Kyle Orton & Brady Quinn have shown the required level to compete for starting role at any place in the league.

Also I'm assuming a Moore for Tebow + 2nd round could be fair, allowing them to keep Orton & Quinn.
Click to expand...



What he is saying is why is Tebow on this list because he sucks at QB. Why would we give a player and a second round pick for someone who is the third best on their team. I would give a 4th for Orton and no more than that. He is an upgrade over Henne but at what cost to our future if we give away the draft for him.
 
Give up a 3rd if you want, to who ever, but we need our 1st for our QB and our 2nd for our new RT............
 
I think Matt Moore is going to beat out chad Henne I know he played bad in Carolina buy looking at his Stats him kevin kolb almost have the same stats different is kevin kolb had more help in Phi Also I think he better then Chad Henne I know his Comp is not better then kolb or henne but eagles system is about making shorts throw for higher comp Chad look good because he keep check down
 
Whose plan is this?

Fortify the LB corpses is my favorite, I guess they keep falling down so maybe if we tied them to a pole it would keep them up.
 
Getting a QB now will not fix the mess the offense is...suck for Luck!!!
 
(sigh)

I've basically come to accept that we will indeed be shackled to Henne for another season.

It is what it is ... I just hope we see more of the rare "good" Chad, and less of the more common "****ty" Chad.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Back
Top Bottom