Vick or Berlin

[WestCoast13]

Who would you rather have Vick or Berlin? We all know Vick has way more talent than Berlin but he is undersized and has off the field issues. Berlin, though, might never develop into an NFL QB.

 

[gmoney]

Berlin has more college experince, more sub-professional experinece in the european league, but i think Vick has a quicker release and can throw longer.

 

[DoLpHiNz34]

Justin Holland

 

[Dolfan4life!]

Where's the "neither" option?

 

[UltraDol-Fan]

I would really like to see what Saban can do with Vick.

 

[FanMarino]

Neither would be a better answer. Culpepper, Harrington and Lemon are the 3 QBs i expect to be on the roster when the season starts.

 

[Dr.Rad]

Vick... holla back

 

[LoneWulF]

both of them are just projects for now, so we may as well take the one with more promise. marcus vick is fast and has a strong arm. high completion percentage. there is value in marcus, whereas there is none in berlin. had marcus kept out of trouble hes a 1st or second round pick. Harrington will be a good backup, Lemon is going to be a starter someday, hes got all the skills. Vick could very possibly be starter a few years from now. Look at all the value wed have at the qb position

 

[Elle Clouds]

is there even a question...vick all the way...sorry brock

 

[SpencerFS]

vick way more upside

 

[utahphinsfan]

I'd rather see the depth chart go; Culpepper, Maddox, Lemon w/ Holland on the practice squad.

Worst case scenario; Daunte, Cleo, Holland w/ Berlin on the PS.

 

[FinIowa85]

MARCUS VICK...........lets see what he can do

 

[Joneal7]

Vick

 

[hestar]

Vickkk...Berlin sucked at UM And will never be good..I hope we get vick.

 

[Philter25]

Seriously, wheres the neither option?

Thats like asking a guy if he wants to be kicked or punched in the balls.