Voting | FinHeaven - Miami Dolphins Forums

Voting

Smoke

Smoke

ZT = HOF
Joined
Jul 28, 2004
Messages
5,090
Reaction score
3
Location
LINCOLN, NE
Even though there are no prizes, after investing this much time, I want to see who wins. Below is a list of the teams that we will be voting for. Only the gm's from the teams listed can vote.

Each gm votes for a 1st, 2nd, and 3rd place team. A 1st place vote is worth 3 pts, a 2nd is worth 2pts, and a 3rd place vote is worth 1 pt. You cannot vote for your own team. All the votes will be added up to see who wins. Voting starts now and goes through June 1st. Post your votes here. Good luck.

1st Green Bay Packers 18pts
2nd Philadelphia Eagles 16pts
3rd New York Jets 15pts
3rd Baltimore Ravens 15pts
Minnesota Vikings 6pts
Cleveland Browns 5pts
Dallas Cowboys 5pts
Washington Redskins 4pts
Jacksonville Jaguars 3pts
Tennessee Titans 3pts
Houston Texans 2pts
New Orleans Saints 2pts
Atlanta Falcons 1pt
Pittsburgh Steelers 1pt
Buffalo Bills 0
St. Louis Rams 0
Carolina Panthers 0
Oakland Raiders 0
 
1) Jets - that draft was sick...
2) Eagles - McNabb, Tomlinson and Chad Johnson.. nuff said
3) Vikings - made a very good team better...

.. of course I would have voted for myself. :D
 
Redskins GM

1. Packers-retooled a very good team but he just made it MUCH better
2. Eagles-LT behind McNabb is enough to push anybody upfront
3. Saints-We all saw what TO did for the Eagles...he will do it for the saints
 
My votes are based on how well the teams were improved rather than the best team. Some of us had better players to work with than others so I didn't judge based on talent alone. Here's my top 3.

1st Green Bay Packers- Solid starters and depth. Excellent in trades and draft picks. Came away with much more than you started with.

2nd New York Jets- The best overall draft and possibly the best in free agency. The only thing I dislike is that you didn't replace D.Brien. The rest of your team looks great.

3rd Washington Redskins- Filled the weakest spots with excellent talent. Solid draft and key free agent pick ups. Defense would dominate.
 
My picks are much different then others I dont really see at all what they saw, I went with teams that improved their team best and took into account what they started out with.

1. The Redskins-Have to give it to ya you have a great team. Made a all-star D better and fixed up on offence as well. If you are beaten by Green Bay, Eagles or Jets you got ripped becaude they started out with better teams, no offence to them.

2. Browns-You went in with a team that had absolutly nothing and you made it into a a very respectable team. I had you at #1 but changed my mind at last secound

3.Cowboys-The great O-line gets no love by anyone else but I will give it to you, strong team all-around, only thing that hurt you was obviously the draft. P.S. I will challenge your self-proclaimed best LB corps with mine.
 
1. Ravens

He really added what I see as an explosive defense, Vick will really mature into more of a pocket passer with Harrison and Burelson as his two targets, add in Todd Heap and its a potent passing attack. Add in the running of Wilis McGahee and Vick's own ability to rush and they can hurt you a whole lot of ways.

Key signing on defense is another guy who can lead by example in Brushi, but its really hard to make the best defense any better but Ravens gets this for making this a team that is hard to touch on both sides.

2. Jets

They already had a solid core to work with, and managed to really help themselves through the draft. They have a solid WR corp after picking Jerry Porter up form FA, and drafting Matt Jones plus McCaerins and it'll give an equation that would make any D-Co dizzy with who to try to cover. They have some depth with drafting Cadillac to be the heir apparent to Curtis Martin and things look good for the the present and future of this offense.

I like the additions of guys like Chris Hovan on defense, and these guy should be brought up the food chain in the league.

3. Browns

For trying their best to turn things around with the cards they were given. Matt Hasselback gives the team a true number one quarterback but lacks the WRs to throw too. However Jackson is a nice big target and could excel at the number two if a top tier WR was able to be brought in. I like the compliment of what Ciatrik Fason does for the team, he'll be able to spell Lee Suggs and maybe steal a few more carries.

Defensively adding someone like Trotter will help the young core of this team, and give it some guidance and leadership.

Not as imposing as the Ravens or Jets but the Browns certainly made themselves a better team more than most of the league.


 
1. Philly Eagles- I know your team was stacked to begin with, and that makes it hard to give you a vote, but brining in guys like Ladanian Tomlinson and Chad Johnson make this team absolutly sick. Bringing in the best RB in the leauge to an elite team is unreal. I like the Thorpe pick up in the draft as well and defensively brining in guys like Doss and Jammer only strengthen a devastating defense.

2.Baltimore Ravens- You got a great QB in there and was still able to keep Boller to learn from an amazing athlete and have one of them avaliable for trade, that was a nice move. I don't really like how you got rid of Lewis but McGahee has great speed and complements Vick nicely. Harrison is a great number 1, but your a little weak at WR beyond that. Hopefully Brusci playes next year, if not that will be a weak spot on your team as well. You still have a star studded defense and this is a pretty good team.

3. Green Bay Packers- I had to give you some love man. You brough alot of talent on this team. I didn't really like how you kind of abandoned most of GB's roster, but this team is definatly a contender. It is sick how 4 of your RB's can be starters on different teams. You got solid wide outs and a good mix of QB's with a young guy to learn in there. You're defense has been upgraded with a nice dose of young players and this could grow into a very successful team.
 
Ok, this was difficult as I thought many GM's did an excellent job, as I must choose three here are the picks of the Jets GM:

1) Green Bay Packers - One of the very best drafts. I love your QB depth and that you also have the young prospect for the future. Your runningback corp. is truly sick, I also love the potential of your WR group. You greatly improved your overall team and added youth in the process, great job!

2) Tennessee Titans - I think you made the right decision in moving McNair now, You have Volek for now until Alex Smith is ready to take over, which shouldn't be long. You brought in Randy Moss, while risky somewhat, no one can deny the impact he can have. Tra Thomas was a huge addition at LT. Your DL is awesome. The only thing I didn't like was losing Troupe and Kinney at TE.

3) Dallas Cowboys - The only thing keeping you from ranking higher on my list is the condition of your QB position, the most important position on the field, and your lack of youth brought in via the draft, you simply must build thru the draft. I Loved the addition of Hines Ward, you made good O-line inprovement. You made some great acquisitions on defense adding Darren Howard, Donnie Edwards, Ronde Barber and Lance Shulters. Good Job overall.
 
Ravens - He got Vick and Harrison When do the tickets go on sale to watch that show.

Eagles - McNabb and LT need I say more

Steelers - J. Lewis will put another team on his back
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Back
Top Bottom