Welker or Camarillo? | FinHeaven - Miami Dolphins Forums

Welker or Camarillo?

C

Chi-Town FinFan

Starter
Joined
Aug 2, 2004
Messages
615
Reaction score
2
If you had to choose, who would you take for this year's Fins? Greg seems as if he's becoming Penny's go-to WR. Wes had a great year with the Pats, but I think it had more to do with the system.

Camarillo is on pace to surpass Welker's best year with the Fins...


I think I would take Camarillo at this point....

Thoughts?
 
Wes Welker.

He's a very good player, Camarillo is good but not as good as Wes Welker. Not to mention Camarillo is working with a much better QB than the QB's Welker got to work with here.
 
If it were an actual choice, I would take Welker as he is a great ST weapon as well. Having said that, I really like Camarillo and dread the upcoming "We should trade Camarillo" threads that are sure to come. IMO, we got a good pick for Welker, we should NOT make the mistake of letting Greg go anywhere.
 
More accurate question, overpriced Welker or Camarillo and Satele? I'll take what we got.
 
I would take welker in a heartbeat. Welker has some amazing hands. Camarillo is playing awesome though. I can not say anything bad about his production. If we can pick up one big physical receiver and use Camarillo as our slot receiver we would be set.
 
Camarillo has the size to be a #2 receiver and is so clutch. He is becoming Miami's version of Wayne Chrebet. I would take the starter over the slot receiver. Although that receiver was very good for us, but remember his best year for us, he had 67 catches at about 10 yds per catch and 1 TD. Plus that was with Chambers on one side, Marty Booker on the other and Randy McMike in the middle. We know who Camarillo has, himself and Pennington. So he really hasn't blown away Camarillo's stats. He did have special teams value, but who would you rather have back there Wes, or Ginn? I'll take Ginn, and Camarillo, and as Gonzo said Samson Satele. IMO it's a no brainer. He is only going to get better.
 
I want guys who want to be here. Welker took parting shots when he left, including saying he would look over at the Patriots sideline and wish he were there. **** him.
 
Wes makes a lot of catches but you don't see him scoring many TD's. I think he finds ways to get open but in the red zone he is not much of a target. I think Camarillo will continue to get many catches and yards. Wes just seems to go down as soon as anyone breathes on him.
 
Welker is a punk who after a week of being traded said he dreamed of being a Patriot while he was playing for us. F that dude, so funny he didn't get a ring last year.
 
Welker plays the slot and Camarillo doesn't. I personally like Camarillo a lot more than Welker. Camarillo is playing a starting role in our roster while Welker is basically playing alongside Randy Moss.

The question is, who is having a better year? Camarillo is having a better year hands down. His 11 reception, over 100 yard performance has been one of the best overall performances this week.
 
Question was who do you take? I'd take Welker. Hate him now, but given the choice of having only one on my team...I take Welker...simple.

Love Camarillo this season though!
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Back
Top Bottom