What Grade Do You Give the Dolphins Draft? | FinHeaven - Miami Dolphins Forums

What Grade Do You Give the Dolphins Draft?

R

RenoFinFan

Pro Bowler
Joined
May 4, 2006
Messages
1,113
Reaction score
0
Now that all is said and done, what GRADE do you give our draft? Comments as to why...

Ted Ginn jr., PR/WR OSU
John Beck, QB BYU
Samson Satele, OL Hawaii
Lorenzon Booker, RB FSU
Paul Soliai, DT Utah
Reagin Mauia, FB Hawaii
Drew Mormino, OL Central Michigan
Kelvin Smith, ILB Syracuse
Brandon Fields, P Michigan State
Abraham Wright, DE Colorado
 
:lol: Forgot to select POLL option button. Tried but won't let me create duplicate...oh well!
 
B. I think our top three picks will be starters no later than 2008, with Soliai and Mauia also having starter potential.
 
I totally agree With A B+ not sure of Lorenzo Booker or Abraham Wright.
All the others all have potential to be starters on this roster in which I like the rest of the draft.
 
The poll on front page is odd. How could a Dolphins fan be "indifferent" about who we drafted? Maybe undecided or unsure but indifferent?
 
D-F....our second day picks were just as rediculous as some of the first day picks. a fullback in the 6th? isnt that what we have eckel and schlesenger for? no db's?
 
I think that I will give it a higher grade than I should cause I have faith in cam and randy. So i will give it a d-
 
Grade : A

We got a big time playmaker and potential offensive rookie of the year. We got the best QB in the draft without trading up. We got a 3rd RB that we needed. We got some depth at OL, Interior DL and possibly LB. Most importantly we kept all of our picks. Well done.
 
i like what we did
B
we didnt hurt our self
we got a real play maker/ game changer
dont get me wrong ronnie is a geart runningback future of our team
Chris chambers is also good but only at the widereciver
we got our selfs a devin hester like player
i hope we dont get trent green and keep daunte i think fits better with the team not the system
 
C

I like most of the draft. I just can't defend an average WR for the 9th pick just because he's fast. We passed up a franchise QB to add insult to injury.
 
RenoFinFan said:
Now that all is said and done, what GRADE do you give our draft? Comments as to why...

Ted Ginn jr., PR/WR OSU
John Beck, QB BYU
Samson Satele, OL Hawaii
Lorenzon Booker, RB FSU
Paul Soliai, DT Utah
Reagin Mauia, FB Hawaii
Drew Mormino, OL Central Michigan
Kelvin Smith, ILB Syracuse
Brandon Fields, P Michigan State
Abraham Wright, DE Colorado
Click to expand...


Even if you don't like this draft, and I don't, I can't give lower than a C-. We just don't know how it's going to turn out. What if Ginn is Hester Jr? What is Satele contributes right away? And most importantly, what if Beck becomes a good starting QB? Then this draft becomes an A. My problem is there's no slam dunks in this list.
 
scout01 said:
I totally agree With A B+ not sure of Lorenzo Booker or Abraham Wright.
All the others all have potential to be starters on this roster in which I like the rest of the draft.
Click to expand...

I agree plus Ginn and Booker bring speed to the offense. Beck can also scramble.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Back
Top Bottom