What was the best bad decision made over the past year?

[LeftHanded21]

what do you think?

 

[PENNDOLPHAN]

Of course its trading welker for a 2 and 7. We got ourselves a potential pro bowl center for a guy who wasnt gonna do **** for us.

 

[DownDolfin]

This is to easy................ Welker.

 

[LtDan]

Drafting Ginn was not a bad decision so I guess I will choose between the other two

 

[LeftHanded21]

Drafting Ginn was not a bad decision so I guess I will choose between the other two

considering our needs at the time, im gonna say it was a bad move turned good(maybe)

 

[emeraldfin]

The Ginn and the Chambers deal are too early to tell so you have to say the Welker deal

 

[LtDan]

considering our needs at the time, im gonna say it was a bad move turned good(maybe)

Why, so we would have had an overrated Brady Quinn to complain about instead?

 

[amspeed13]

considering our needs at the time, im gonna say it was a bad move turned good(maybe)

??? isnt that a good move that didnt look great? :D

 

[Etuoo33]

Simply put, the Chambers deal brought us Henne, Marino incarnate.

 

[phinfanNY08]

definately welker. how cam and the moron club didnt see what this guy brought to the table was astonishing. not only was he a great slot reciever but he was a hell of a special teams player. that second round pick got us john beck....:shakeno:

bad decision

 

[dlockz]

I misread the question. Welker was the best move but trading Chambers an drafting Ginn were far from great decisions.

 

[Bumrush]

Trading Chambers at peak value was awesome. Do you guys think Chambers would survive the Parcells regime? Chambers was HIGHLY overrated and disappeared for weeks at a time. Getting a 2nd round pick for him was highway robbery.

 

[Vaark]

If Pennington were to be voting, no question he'd choose "trading Welker" as the worst decision; Henne would probably have selected "trading Chambers" although I believe the irony would be that the 2nd we got translated into his pick. As much as I think Ginn will turn out to be a goodie, especially now that he's shown no fear catching over the middle, I'd have to say drafting Ginn instead of Willis.

 

[dlockz]

Trading Chambers at peak value was awesome. Do you guys think Chambers would survive the Parcells regime? Chambers was HIGHLY overrated and disappeared for weeks at a time. Getting a 2nd round pick for him was highway robbery.

Chambers was not overrated , he just never had a friggin Qb. I love how Chambers was overrated but Ginn was such an outstanding pick.

 

[Bumrush]

Chambers was not overrated , he just never had a friggin Qb. I love how Chambers was overrated but Ginn was such an outstanding pick.

Chambers was not an elite WR with the Dolphins. I love how every single Chambers apologist blames the QB's for his butterfingers and poor route running. I think a second for Chambers should be listed as a smart move, not the best bad decision.