What will the AJ haters do...

[nyjunc]

when Chad Pennington plays a whole season

I'll take Chad only playong 12 or 13 games or playing at 80% over AJ any day of the week.

 

[Sal Lisitano]

add in fumbles lost -3 points(fumbles recovered by qb or other don't count) and it's on.

Go GUS. :D.

okay...in GUS We Trust!!!

Go Fins!!!

 

[Justasportsfan]

okay...in GUS We Trust!!!

Go Fins!!!

Just to make sure, this is between JP and AJ. Even if Gus beats AJ, you still lose by mid season even if AJ doesn't gain any points from the bench.

 

[Sal Lisitano]

Just to make sure, this is between JP and AJ. Even if Gus beats AJ, you still lose by mid season even if AJ doesn't gain any points from the bench.

Um...NO.

If Gus beats A.J. in camp than its between Gus and JP.

If A.J. wins the job in camp than its between A.J. and JP.

If either qb gets replaced...bets over. it would make no sense then...unless you want to combine pts.

so...is this for the whole regular season? or from the first 8 games.

Go Fins!!!

 

[Justasportsfan]

Um...NO.

If Gus beats A.J. in camp than its between Gus and JP.

If A.J. wins the job in camp than its between A.J. and JP.

If either qb gets replaced...bets over. it would make no sense then...unless you want to combine pts.

so...is this for the whole regular season? or from the first 8 games.

Go Fins!!!

No.no.no. You guys were blasting JP and so I said, it doesn't matter, that means Gus is better than AJ therefore losses his starting previledges. We are talking about 2 unproven qb's. I'm at least willing to take a risk w/ our unproven qb against your unproven qb who's had a 4 yr. headstart.

Since you guys are so sure JP will struggle I was willing to bet he does better than Feeley.

 

[Sal Lisitano]

No.no.no. You guys were blasting JP and so I said, it doesn't matter, that means Gus is better than AJ therefore losses his starting previledges. We are talking about 2 unproven qb's. I'm at least willing to take a risk w/ our unproven qb against your unproven qb who's had a 4 yr. headstart.

#1 I never blasted JP...I said he had some attitude issues in the past. I never said that he would flop.

Okay...if this is between A.J. and J.P. obviously the bet will only be fair if A.J. becomes the starter and keeps his job...then it would not be fair if he gets replaced by Gus or Sage...how the hell do you expect that to be fair.

Sounds like you're afraid of Gus...which you made fun of plenty of times.

To make it fair we may have to change the rules a little. we may have to combine the pts. of all the qbs...due to injury or benching...or else its only fair if A.J. gets and keeps the job.

this works out for you b/c JP is already the penciled in starter...and as of now...we don't know who will be the starter in Miami.

Go Fins!!!

 

[Justasportsfan]

and how do you know this? he has no attitude problem? that was the biggest knock on him coming out of college...that he was a little baby (not in those exact words) and that he acted like a pre-madonna (not in those exact words) but you get the point...I hope. If you didn't hear this...or know about this I'll be really suprised. Funny how most of you Bills fans are selective and only remember what you want to remember. You are a homer in the worst way...how are his work ethic and promise undeniable...so you even follow him every where he goes? You don't know what he does...every second of the day (well I hope you don't )

Go Fins!!!

Doesn't this mean that his arrogance will bring out the worse in him? If so then you don't have to worry about him struggling with his teammates because he will, if he is as arrogant as you say he is.

If Gus beats out Aj, that simply means we were right, AJ is nothing more than a back-up at best losing to a has been. AJ is learning a new system but has 4 years headstart over JP who has been learning a system from the bench.

It wouldn't be fair since Gus has had years under linehan's system. So my point is, who's the better unproven qb/ I say it's JP. If you agree with me then maybe this bet was meant for Rafael and FTP and not you.

I am pitting my unproven qb against yours is what I am trying to prove.
Just so you know, Holcomb could beat out JP in preseason too. Donahoe and Mularkey has made it clear. Part of the reason why Jp is figured as the starter is because he's doing very well and beating Holcomb at camp.

 

[Sal Lisitano]

"It wouldn't be fair since Gus has had years under linehan's system. So my point is, who's the better unproven qb/ I say it's JP. If you agree with me then maybe this bet was meant for Rafael and FTP and not you."

So...this statement you just made...shows that it also isn't fair for A.J. either...right?

Now...Justa...read my post...all I was saying is that JP was ??? about his attitude...I'm not saying that this has or has not changed or may or may not affect his play on the field...

Go Fins!!!

 

[Justasportsfan]

So...this statement you just made...shows that it also isn't fair for A.J. either...right?

I thought Aj was responsible for taking the eagles to the playoffs? He now has an OL , a rb and most of all a coach.

Now...Justa...read my post...all I was saying is that JP was ??? about his attitude...I'm not saying that this has or has not changed or may or may not affect his play on the field...

Go Fins!!!

Then this bet wasn't for you then. My bad. Where's FTP and rafael ?

 

[Sal Lisitano]

I thought Aj was responsible for taking the eagles to the playoffs? He now has an OL , a rb and most of all a coach.
Then this bet wasn't for you then. My bad. Where's FTP and rafael ?

I believe I never mentioned aj and the eagles in this thread. again..gus has more experience in Linehan's system...so its also unfair for aj...i don't feel like gus and aj are starting on equal ground...gus has the edge right now.

i will admit...jp is the most unexperienced qb between him and aj...so you are taking a risk...but i just don't see it as being a fair bet until the season starts b/c gus could very well beat out aj...so by your thinking...you would win the bet pretty easily this way...why would anyone take that bet?

Go Fins!!!

 

[PhinBeck]

dam this thread is still going.

 

[Justasportsfan]

i will admit...jp is the most unexperienced qb between him and aj...so you are taking a risk...but i just don't see it as being a fair bet until the season starts.

Go Fins!!!

It's a fair bet to those who think that the bills will take a step back w/ a rookie qb but the fins won't w/ AJ as the qb. Almost everyone here thinks that AJ is the starter.

Now that you're out,NUBLAR, You in?

 

[FIN-IN-RI]

i'd rather have scott zolak than jp lossman

 

[rafael]

Hey Sal, Feelthepain and Rafael. You guys wanna make an avatar and sig bet that JP will have better nos. than Feeley by mid season?

If Gus beats out Feeley at camp the bet is still on. The only thing that pushes the bet is if someone goes down w/ an injury.Cmon , put your money where your mouth is.

Let's go by Football fantasy nos.

I said I think they are both going to suck. The only reason I prefer AJ is that he has a lower salary which we could cut fairly easily after another season of sucking.

 

[Avalanche of Wins]

at least feeley has a hot girlfriend