What would u rate our players | FinHeaven - Miami Dolphins Forums

What would u rate our players

C

CChambers7284

The Biggest Fins Fan from CT
Joined
Jan 9, 2005
Messages
1,199
Reaction score
4
Age
35
Location
connecticut
Madden style (0 to 99)

QB
Frerotte- 77
Feeley- 71
Rosenfles- 70

RB
Ricky- 88
Brown- 84
Gordon- 74
Morris- 76

FB
Evans- 77

TE
McMike- 94
Lee- 73
Perry- 60 (but as a long snapper, 90)

WR
Chambers- 90
Booker- 86
Boston- 85
Thompson- 78
Gilmore- 74
Welker- 68 (90 as a returner)

LT
MacIntosh- 79
Carey- 75

LG- James 80
Cook- 61

C
McKinney- 74
Smith- 77

RG
Hadnot- 77
Whitley- 75

RT
MacDougle- 88
St. Clair- 78

RE- Taylor 97
Roth- 77

LE- Holliday- 85
Bowens- 81

DT
Carter- 92
Traylor- 88
Zgonina- 89
Chester- 86

LOLB
Spragan- 79
Moore- 76

MLb
Thomas-97
Crowder- 76
Pope- 75

ROLB
Seau- 89
Glenn- 74
Ayanbedejo- 60 (85 on special teams)

CB
Madison- 91
Howard- 80
Edwards- 79
Daniels- 74

FS
Shultrs- 87
Tillman- 78

SS
Tesucky- 85
Bell- 71

Mare- 87
Turk- 84
 
I'll be very interested to do this again at the end of the season. I'll bet Roth and Brown make it into the 90's.
Of course they haven't actually played a regular season game yet. But my gut tells me they'll be great.
Good post.
 
people need to stop overating Roth.. he has struggled so far because he is a rookie. This is gonna be a tough season for him. He'll get there, but not any time soon.
 
its still preseason...i don't know if roth will make it into the 90's, but he is not overated. roth has an extra gear most players don't and a sense for the game that you rarely see. football is not all about #'s..if we were ranking dedication or heart roth would be a 99 and that's a good place to start, this kid will be very solid and was a steal where we got him!

i do agree with most your ratings..nice
 
dolfan005 said:
its still preseason...i don't know if roth will make it into the 90's, but he is not overated. roth has an extra gear most players don't and a sense for the game that you rarely see. football is not all about #'s..if we were ranking dedication or heart roth would be a 99 and that's a good place to start, this kid will be very solid and was a steal where we got him!

i do agree with most your ratings..nice
Click to expand...
he will be very solid, you are right... but I maintain that he will have typical rookie growing pains this season. He is overhyped, should i say, not overrated, by a lot of people.
 
Ferotte-76;Feeley-75 Rosenfels-71 Berlin-73

Williams-91 Brown-86 Morris-82 Minor-79 Gordan-82

Chambers-88 Booker-84 Boston-86 Thompson-78 Newson-77 Gilmore-78 Mann-77 Welker-80

McMicheal-86 Lee-71

Carey-85 McDougle-82 McKinney-72 Hadnot-77 James-83 Smith-77


Madison-88 Howard-80 Shulters-84 McDaniels-80 Bell-82 Bua-77 Poole-85 Jones-85

Thomas-90 Seau-86 Crowder-85 Pope-80 Moore-79 Ayanbedjo-77 Jenkins-79 Spragan-81

Taylor-95 Bowens-82 Holliday-84 Carter-84 Roth-79

Shaw-82 Traylor-85 Wright-72 Vickerson-79 Zgonia-85 Chester-88

Turk-85 Jones-82
Omare-88 Welker-80

Saban-90
Linehan-88
Garret-65
Baggett-85
Houck-88
Smith-80
Quinn-80
Edwards-77
Phillips-84
Armstrong-86
 
CChambers7284 said:
Madden style (0 to 99)

QB
Frerotte- 77
Feeley- 71
Rosenfles- 70

RB
Ricky- 88
Brown- 84
Gordon- 74
Morris- 76

FB
Evans- 77

TE
McMike- 94
Lee- 73
Perry- 60 (but as a long snapper, 90)

WR
Chambers- 90
Booker- 86
Boston- 85
Thompson- 78
Gilmore- 74
Welker- 68 (90 as a returner)

LT
MacIntosh- 79
Carey- 75

LG- James 80
Cook- 61

C
McKinney- 74
Smith- 77

RG
Hadnot- 77
Whitley- 75

RT
MacDougle- 88
St. Clair- 78

RE- Taylor 97
Roth- 77

LE- Holliday- 85
Bowens- 81

DT
Carter- 92
Traylor- 88
Zgonina- 89
Chester- 86

LOLB
Spragan- 79
Moore- 76

MLb
Thomas-97
Crowder- 76
Pope- 75

ROLB
Seau- 89
Glenn- 74
Ayanbedejo- 60 (85 on special teams)

CB
Madison- 91
Howard- 80
Edwards- 79
Daniels- 74

FS
Shultrs- 87
Tillman- 78

SS
Tesucky- 85
Bell- 71

Mare- 87
Turk- 84
Click to expand...


and kay jay harris-80 :evil:
 
you can't give Houck an 83!!!

he deserves a higher rating than Saban...
 
finsnchips said:
you can't give Houck an 83!!!

he deserves a higher rating than Saban...
Click to expand...


here you go

houck-95

saban-90

hows that :evil:
 
finsnchips said:
you can't give Houck an 83!!!

he deserves a higher rating than Saban...
Click to expand...


OOOPS SLIGHT OVERSIGHT
HOUCK-88
 
did anyone see that in the Lindy's guide they rated Saban as a 70 and the lowest rank in the league??

obviously its because he is a rookie NFL HC, but still...
 
In the real Madden, Frerotte and Feeley are both 85s i believe, maybe 84.
Feeley is the default starter. Ricky is not in the new Madden. Ronnie is rated 86, very high for a rookie. Roth was about 76 or 77. None of our receivers are higher than 89 (chambers). McMichael is a 90. Mare has fallen to a 90. zach somehow passed up JT from last year, they are now 96 and 95 respectively.

It is also no surprise that the overall team rating for miami is only 70.
 
i think feeley and frerotte are both 78... ronnie is 84 and roth is 79.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Back
Top Bottom