What would you trade for andrew luck? | Page 2 | FinHeaven - Miami Dolphins Forums

What would you trade for andrew luck?

The big question is IF. How many QBs over the past couple of years have turned out to be complete busts.

All the movement for luck should be done at the end of the season if need be.

Asking the players to tank the season for some college kid would create a far bigger embarrassment than Ross' trip to Cali. It just doesn't happen.
 
These might be some of the most ridiculous posts I've ever read! The idea of giving up an entire draft is retarded, but two? That is just idiotic. The draft does mean something if you get decent players. Some pan out nicely some do not. I can tell you what the outcome most likely would be. It would be just like Herschel Walker getting traded from the Cowboys to the Vikings for what turned out to be 11 players in return. The Vikings still sucked and the Cowboys went on to win three championships, by drafting Oh my Irving, Smith, and Aikman to name a few. There isn't enough talent on this team to even contemplated making such a stupid move. The Peyton Manning reference is just dumb too. Remember in the beginning they drafted Faulk and Harrison to help him out. He's always been surrounded by weapons.
 
FOr Luck I'll give 2 first rounders, 2 second rounders, Wake, Bess and Starks, Davis Anything they want. Once you have a guy like Luck a real Franchise QB the rest of the team doesnt matter that much. Look at the Pats last on defense but they got Brady so they are 3-1 reguardless and will be in the playoffs. Looks the Indy when they got Manning does not matter where thier defense ranks how long the other team possess the ball they will win and will always be in the Playoffs. I say we do anything it takes to get Luck and then build our defense once we have him
 
If we give up the all our picks for the year or 2, I think we should have Mike Ditka make the announcement in dreads!!!
 
Romy148 said:
FOr Luck I'll give 2 first rounders, 2 second rounders, Wake, Bess and Starks, Davis Anything they want. Once you have a guy like Luck a real Franchise QB the rest of the team doesnt matter that much. Look at the Pats last on defense but they got Brady so they are 3-1 reguardless and will be in the playoffs. Looks the Indy when they got Manning does not matter where thier defense ranks how long the other team possess the ball they will win and will always be in the Playoffs. I say we do anything it takes to get Luck and then build our defense once we have him
Click to expand...
and if Luck should get hurt early on??? How many years did you just throw away?????
 
I wouldn't trade too much for him. QB's are historically hit or miss and there are some pretty good QB prospects coming out this year besides him. I'd much rather keep future firsts and 2nds and end up with Barkley or Jones. I think Luck is better than those two, don't get me wrong. But I don't think the difference is going to be worth all the extra players that you're going to be giving up to trade for Luck.
 
I think Russell Wilson ends up the better pro...for whatever team takes a "chance" on him, due to his height. He's Drew Brees.
 
Heatking said:
If it comes down to it and we have the 5th pick and had to trade up to number 1 what would u give up?

im willing to give up something like

2 - 1st rounders
2 - 2nd rounders
2 - 3rd rounders
2 - 4th rounders
2 - 5th rounders
2 - 6th rounders
2 - 7th rounders

i honestly think this is what it will take to get luck. 2 complete drafts and i would say he is all worth it... would u rather have a 22 year old payton manning or jared odrick, koa misi, john jerry, aj edds, nolan carroll, reshad jones, mike pouncey, daniel thomas? the only 2 decent players out of those two drafts look like pouncey and thomas... and who takes a center at 15??!!?

the point im trying to make is draft picks are overrated because the draft is such a gamble... you simply take the best QB prospect EVER and roll with him, idc who we have to give up for him.
Click to expand...

Not being realistic here. Everyone and the dog next door knows that whoever has the #1 pick is "keeping" it and drafting Luck. No point in playing fanciful impossibilities. If Luck is as touted as they say he is.... it doesnt matter who picks #1 overall... Luck is their pick. So our "only" scenario for Luck is to "make sure" we lose most of our games and land the worst record in the league.
 
If it means, losing to the Jets, Pats, and Bills twice... then we need to do it. But we all know, that aint happening either. We are probably going to end up with a top 6 pick and its not going to be Andrew Luck. :(
 
My god we gotta have some of the most unrealistic fans ever....This team is so lacking of overall talent that if you dumped to entire drafts we might as well find a new team to root for because Miami is done.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Back
Top Bottom