What would you trade for andrew luck? | Page 3 | FinHeaven - Miami Dolphins Forums

What would you trade for andrew luck?

The highest offer + 7th round pick.

We just went through a decade of crappy draft picks.

Might as well use those on a potential franchise QB.
 
MiamiMuss said:
My god we gotta have some of the most unrealistic fans ever....This team is so lacking of overall talent that if you dumped to entire drafts we might as well find a new team to root for because Miami is done.
Click to expand...

So save draft picks to draft bad players?

Repeat of 2000s...No thanks.
 
I'd give up the entire draft atleast. Next year's first-fourth. Might as well make it the entire thing geeze... But maybe a player or so and less picks? Like I think it would honestly depend on what team we are trading with.
 
Canadianfishfan said:
The big question is IF. How many QBs over the past couple of years have turned out to be complete busts.

All the movement for luck should be done at the end of the season if need be.

Asking the players to tank the season for some college kid would create a far bigger embarrassment than Ross' trip to Cali. It just doesn't happen.
Click to expand...



if i was a player id be willing to tank to get rid of Henne. You have the best QB in 20 years in the draft and little to no chance he is a bust. You do whatever it takes to get the final heir apparent to Marino
 
Heatking said:
If it comes down to it and we have the 5th pick and had to trade up to number 1 what would u give up?

im willing to give up something like

2 - 1st rounders
2 - 2nd rounders
2 - 3rd rounders
2 - 4th rounders
2 - 5th rounders
2 - 6th rounders
2 - 7th rounders

i honestly think this is what it will take to get luck. 2 complete drafts and i would say he is all worth it... would u rather have a 22 year old payton manning or jared odrick, koa misi, john jerry, aj edds, nolan carroll, reshad jones, mike pouncey, daniel thomas? the only 2 decent players out of those two drafts look like pouncey and thomas... and who takes a center at 15??!!?

the point im trying to make is draft picks are overrated because the draft is such a gamble... you simply take the best QB prospect EVER and roll with him, idc who we have to give up for him.
Click to expand...

would you take mangold at 15?? i think so...and if pouncey turns out to be something special he is well worth the #15 pick. center is the most important part of the line. you do realize we are actually running the ball up the middle this year right???well.....when DT is running anyway.
 
if by some miracle we actually win a game or two this year and we need to move up a few spots, i would part ways with either Marshall, dansby, wake. any one of those guys would do some good in moving up. The reason why i say those guys, i love marshall but is he really the best thing for a rookie QB, dansby is the highest paid MLB for what??? and wake, love him but are you gonna want to pay him atleast 10 mill a year??
 
Heatking said:
If it comes down to it and we have the 5th pick and had to trade up to number 1 what would u give up?

im willing to give up something like

2 - 1st rounders
2 - 2nd rounders
2 - 3rd rounders
2 - 4th rounders
2 - 5th rounders
2 - 6th rounders
2 - 7th rounders

i honestly think this is what it will take to get luck. 2 complete drafts and i would say he is all worth it... would u rather have a 22 year old payton manning or jared odrick, koa misi, john jerry, aj edds, nolan carroll, reshad jones, mike pouncey, daniel thomas? the only 2 decent players out of those two drafts look like pouncey and thomas... and who takes a center at 15??!!?

the point im trying to make is draft picks are overrated because the draft is such a gamble... you simply take the best QB prospect EVER and roll with him, idc who we have to give up for him.
Click to expand...

Whatever it takes, whatever it takes....
 
I want him just as bad as anyone else but it's unreal how so many of you guys here already have him wearing 3 super bowls rings, an 11 time pro bowler, 5 time MVP, and a first ballot hall of famer.
 
testtubetimmy said:
Look at the teams that will most likely be in the top 5. Most have quarterbacks or projects they've already drafted. Rams have Bradford, Chiefs have Cassel, Vikings drafted Christian Ponder last year. Colts still have Manning, but it's clear they're going to want his heir apparent. But I think Manning plays for another 5-6 years, and I'm not sure if Luck will be able to wait that long before starting. So really, in my opinion, it comes down to us and the Colts.
Click to expand...

Cassell ain't that good to pass up on Luck. KC would be stupid not to pick him.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Back
Top Bottom