Whatever happened to that phycoligist that can predict if a QB is good or not? | FinHeaven - Miami Dolphins Forums

Whatever happened to that phycoligist that can predict if a QB is good or not?

The Samurai

Seasoned Veteran
Joined
Aug 16, 2005
Messages
624
Reaction score
0
There was a thread on this awhike back but I cant find it. For those that dont know, I believe this guy is a phycoligist from the L.A. Area who can predict if someone is going to be an elite NFL QB. There was a guy who brought in his 10 yr old son and he told him that he has the mental capacity to be an elite NFL QB. He predicted that Peyton was gonna be an NFL QB years before entering the NFL, while he said that his brother Eli wasnt. This guy is a 100% accurate in QB evaluations. I am wondering what are his latest evaluations of college QB'S.:)
 
Dude I am dead serious. He says that the success of an NFL QB is based on how his brain processes information. I wish I can dig up that thread. I think Muck was the one that started it.
 
wouldnt he be a pshycic? not a pshycologist?

Mod Note: He's a psychiatrist or a psychologist. And psychics are like what Miss Cleo claimed to be.
 
So you think there is a guy that is 100% at predicting NFL QB success and sorry...you are a Bills fan. I have lots of Bills Fan friends but I had to note that. Seriously....


give us a break. And you are assuming E Manning will not be good. OK
I would love to see the list of people he predicted and the ones he said would not be good.

Actually, no no no I would not!
 
Is this the same guy that "types" basketball players ?? I saw an hour show on that a while back and it was pretty impressive...seemed like he could pick out the "chokers" VS "clutch types" from body language facial expressions etc.
 
I heard an interview with Beathard. He said that Jonathan P. Niednagel told the Chargers unequivocally that Leaf would be a bust. Unfortunately the Chargers had already traded up in the draft before hiring him. I don't know if this guy is a 100%, but he his system is based on Jung's philosophies and he just says people process info in different ways. Some of those ways aren't condusive to being an NFL QB. I remember reading that he grabed a kid who had never played football before. Brain typed and said this kid (with coaching and avoiding injuries)can be a top 5 pick. He started in college as a freshman, I believe, until he got injured.
 
SF Dolphin Fan said:
We need to hire him!

Many teams do. He gives them very specific info on prospects which rarely hear. With Saban's psych interests it wouldn't surprise me if the Dolphins do/will.
 
i did the questionaire and my brain type was ESTP, what ever that means...:hmmm:
 
rafael said:
I heard an interview with Beathard. He said that Jonathan P. Niednagel told the Chargers unequivocally that Leaf would be a bust. Unfortunately the Chargers had already traded up in the draft before hiring him. I don't know if this guy is a 100%, but he his system is based on Jung's philosophies and he just says people process info in different ways. Some of those ways aren't condusive to being an NFL QB. I remember reading that he grabed a kid who had never played football before. Brain typed and said this kid (with coaching and avoiding injuries)can be a top 5 pick. He started in college as a freshman, I believe, until he got injured.

Niednagel was hardly alone. I remember a thread in a different forum immediately preceeding that draft in which many Washington State students who went to class with Ryan Leaf said he was the laziest and least dedicated goofoff on campus. They absolutely couldn't believe the NFL was going to overlook all that and consider the athletic skill alone.
 
Back
Top Bottom