Obviously the Super Bowl wins, particularly the first. The second win was a foregone conclusion and a loss would have been stunning.
The '74 playoff game at Oakland was the most devastating loss in team history, but it was also a fantastic game. If you disregard the outcome, that was probably the greatest game in Dolphin history in terms of drama and quality of play. It opened with a kickoff return for TD by Nat Moore and remained edge-of-your-seat nerve wracking throughout. Absolutely no contest between the caliber of that game and the laughable ineptitude of the '81 game vs. the Chargers, two remarkably flawed teams repeatedly determined to surrender advantage through unforced errors like turnovers and shanked FGs or divoted FGs.
Al DeRogatis was the premier TV football analyst of the '60s and through the mid '70s. He partnered with Curt Gowdy on NBC and did the call of that '74 playoff game. At the end of the telecast, DeRogatis called it perhaps the best football game he had ever seen.
I guarantee DeRogatis would never have said anything similar about that '81 mess.
Dr. Z of Sports Illustrated calls DeRogatis his #1 football analyst of all time so it's hardly a throwaway opinion.
The '71 Christmas Day game at Kansas City obviously belongs on a list like this. So does the '72 AFC Championship Game at Pittsburgh. That was hellish to come out of there with a win against a young brute team, particularly the way the game opened. The bold decision to yank Morrall at halftime and replace with Griese adds a variable that boosts the intrigue and status of that game.
And I'm surprised the '78 Monday Night loss at Houston isn't prominently featured in a thread like this. It has long been considered one of the best Monday Night games ever, a resurgent Griese vs. Earl Campbell.