Which QB will do the best coming off injury? | FinHeaven - Miami Dolphins Forums

Which QB will do the best coming off injury?

Who will do the Best?

  • Daunte Culpepper

    Votes: 65 80.2%

  • Carson Palmer

    Votes: 11 13.6%

  • Ben Roethlsberger

    Votes: 4 4.9%

  • Drew Brees

    Votes: 1 1.2%
  • Total voters
    81
phillyphinphan4

phillyphinphan4

Scout Team
Joined
Feb 10, 2006
Messages
35
Reaction score
0
Location
Philly
Personally I think Cpep will have a great year because he is so ahead of schedule. Palmer isn't as ahead of his injury a Cpep and his injury looked a lot worse. So i don't think he'll do that great, but he doesn't run. Roethlesberger's injury won't affect his game much so he'll do good also. Brees will have a off year because he is the only one who had an injury with his shoulder. Also he does'nt have any WR's.

:dolphins: Go Phins :dolphins:
 
I can see the same thing coming everyone picking pepper. But i say brees will have the best year along with pepper.
 
Yeah, this poll is going to be biased. I, however, do believe that Culpepper will have the best season out of all those QB's, although I think Roethlisberger's TEAM has the best shot for overall success.
 
Roth's injury wasn't football related...but I guess you could have him in there.
From the reports I've seen, I think Daunte is in front. I think Palmer will do fine this year as he has a good supporting cast. Now Brees on the other hand, I think, is going to struggle. Not just because of the new team, but because the injury he sustained is really going to effect how he throws. As a former profressional baseball player (pitcher) I've had three shoulder operations. It's a really tough injury to come back from and it takes a long time to get comfortable physically and mentally. The test will be when he has to let one go 40-50 yards down the field. If there's any hint of pain, it's all over for his psyche. He will start to short arm the ball, natural self preservation, and it will be Chad Pennington-ish. And Brees never had a strong arm to begin with, so it's going to be tough for him.
So out of the guys you've listed, I think all will do well outside of Brees.
 
Well I picked DP, not because of homerism, but for the following reasons

Carson had a good year last year, so did Breese, and Ben nefore the injuries...

Now DC had a terrible start to his season with all the issues the team had. His performance was not up to par with the other QBs listed.

So the question in the poll is, who will do the best after coming off injury? Barring a terrible performance, DC should have better stats this year, than last year before his injury...

Does anyone agree?
 
Disnardo said:
Well I picked DP, not because of homerism, but for the following reasons

Carson had a good year last year, so did Breese, and Ben nefore the injuries...

Now DC had a terrible start to his season with all the issues the team had. His performance was not up to par with the other QBs listed.

So the question in the poll is, who will do the best after coming off injury? Barring a terrible performance, DC should have better stats this year, than last year before his injury...

Does anyone agree?
Click to expand...

Good logic, but the question isn't, who will have better stats this year compared to last year, it is, who will be the best quarterback this year compared to eachother.
 
I hope Carson or Ben dosent come back good.:shakeno:
 
xDOLPHINSx said:
Good logic, but the question isn't, who will have better stats this year compared to last year, it is, who will be the best quarterback this year compared to eachother.
Click to expand...

Nope Sorry, I don't analize the question the same way you do...:wink:

Which QB will do the best coming off injury? Daunte had a unspectacular year before his injury, so...

If the other guys are just as good with their stats (QBR, comp %, etc.), therefore not showing improving after injury, and Daunte improves from his 72 QBR last year, he will show improvement, compare to the othe QBs...:wink:

It irrelevant whether Daunte did not have a better year than the others...
 
phillyphinphan4 said:
Personally I think Cpep will have a great year because he is so ahead of schedule. Palmer isn't as ahead of his injury a Cpep and his injury looked a lot worse. So i don't think he'll do that great, but he doesn't run. Roethlesberger's injury won't affect his game much so he'll do good also. Brees will have a off year because he is the only one who had an injury with his shoulder. Also he does'nt have any WR's.

:dolphins: Go Phins :dolphins:
Click to expand...
.


I think CPep will have the best season, but the Aints do have Horn, Stallworth, Bethel Johnson and Devery Henderson...
 
Well there all dolphin fans in the NFL section, but there are also some bills, steelers, jets, NE, Raider fans, etc that go there. So it might be better if this thread was put there, for a less biased poll, if that's what you want.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Back
Top Bottom