Which scenario on draft day do you prefer | FinHeaven - Miami Dolphins Forums

Which scenario on draft day do you prefer

Austin Tatious

Starter
Club Member
Joined
Sep 7, 2004
Messages
8,249
Reaction score
8,979
Option A.

1. OT Levi Brown, PSU
2. WR Robert Meacham, 6'3 4.45 Tenn
3. QB Trent Edwards, Stanford
4. TE Matt Spaeth, Minnesota
6. K Justin Medlock, UCLA
7. ILB Dedrick Harrington, Missouri

Option B.
1. WR Ted Ginn, wr 6'0, 4.3. Ohio State
2. OLB LaMarr Woodley Michigan
3. OT Doug Free, Northern Illinois
4. TE Matt Spaeth, Minnesota
6. K Justin Medlock, UCLA
7. ILB Dedrick Harrington, Missouri

Option C
1. WR Ted Ginn, wr 6'0, 4.3. Ohio State
2. OT Joe Staley, CMU
3. OLB Prescott Burgess, UM
4. TE Matt Spaeth, Minnesota
6. K Justin Medlock, UCLA
7. ILB Dedrick Harrington, Missouri

Option D
1. QB Brady Quinn, ND
2. OT Joe Staley, CMU
3. WR Johnnie Lee Higgins UTEP
4. TE Matt Spaeth, Minnesota
6. K Justin Medlock, UCLA
7. ILB Dedrick Harrington, Missouri

Option E
1. QB Brady Quinn ND
2. WR Robert Meacham Tenn
3. OT Doug Free, Northern Illinois
4. TE Matt Spaeth, Minnesota
6. K Justin Medlock, UCLA
7. ILB Dedrick Harrington, Missouri



Personally, I think any of those 5 scenarios would be great. And obviously, you can run any permutation of the different possibilities.
 
WE ARE NOT DRAFTING A KICKER!!! It doesn't matter who is out there. We have Mare and Prater on the roster now, and I'll assume that it will be on of those two guys who will make the roster and be our K.

Other than that, those options seem fine, without Medlock.
 
I'd like to see something like this:

1. Levi Brown LT Penn State
2. Ryan Kalil C USC
3. Trent Edwards QB Stanford
4. Stewart Bradley OLB Nebraska
6. Stanley Doughty NT South Carolina
7. Matt Trannon WR Michigan State
 
Option A.

1. OT Levi Brown, PSU
2. WR Robert Meacham, 6'3 4.45 Tenn
3. QB Trent Edwards, Stanford
4. TE Matt Spaeth, Minnesota
6. K Justin Medlock, UCLA
7. ILB Dedrick Harrington, Missouri

Option B.
1. WR Ted Ginn, wr 6'0, 4.3. Ohio State
2. OLB LaMarr Woodley Michigan
3. OT Doug Free, Northern Illinois
4. TE Matt Spaeth, Minnesota
6. K Justin Medlock, UCLA
7. ILB Dedrick Harrington, Missouri

Option C
1. WR Ted Ginn, wr 6'0, 4.3. Ohio State
2. OT Joe Staley, CMU
3. OLB Prescott Burgess, UM
4. TE Matt Spaeth, Minnesota
6. K Justin Medlock, UCLA
7. ILB Dedrick Harrington, Missouri

Option D
1. QB Brady Quinn, ND
2. OT Joe Staley, CMU
3. WR Johnnie Lee Higgins UTEP
4. TE Matt Spaeth, Minnesota
6. K Justin Medlock, UCLA
7. ILB Dedrick Harrington, Missouri

Option E
1. QB Brady Quinn ND
2. WR Robert Meacham Tenn
3. OT Doug Free, Northern Illinois
4. TE Matt Spaeth, Minnesota
6. K Justin Medlock, UCLA
7. ILB Dedrick Harrington, Missouri



Personally, I think any of those 5 scenarios would be great. And obviously, you can run any permutation of the different possibilities.

Either E or D would be great. But I'm not sure we should spend anything more than a 7th rounder for a kicker even if it is Medlock.
 
A would be the smartest draft. Although im far from sold on levi brown.
 
D..if quinn is there at the 9th pick, we MUST take him... and higgins is ginn part 2
 
A would be the smartest draft. Although im far from sold on levi brown.

word from the senior bowl practices is that brown is playing really well. On 1-on-1 drills, he overpowered Woodley and even knocked him to the ground. He has the quickest feet out of all the Olinemen.
 
I'd like to see something like this:

1. Levi Brown LT Penn State
2. Ryan Kalil C USC
3. Trent Edwards QB Stanford
4. Stewart Bradley OLB Nebraska
6. Stanley Doughty NT South Carolina
7. Matt Trannon WR Michigan State


This one but except replace Levi Brown with Tedd Ginn Jr
 
This one but except replace Levi Brown with Tedd Ginn Jr

You raise a good point MrEd. I considered putting Ginn there, I really did, but I just can't picture us not addressing the O-line with what Cameron said about building the team from the inside-out. Obviously, Centers are very rarely 1st round picks, I know Mangold was this year, but I don't think any are in this class. So my next logical thought was to take Brown, considering we've not had a quality LT since Richmond Webb and the fact I'm not entirely sold that Chambers is turning into a dud. But Ginn would be fine w/me at that spot as well, so long as we address Left Tackle in Free Agency or in rd. 2 if Kalil isn't there, but after hearing the reports on Brown, I had to put him there.
 
option a or c is what i like. options w/quinn i just don't think will happen.
 
maybe wishful thinking or smokin the good stuff, but can anyone think of a trade down possibility that could net us levi, woodley, and meacham. its a stretch but if we could some how come away with both ne's pick(maybe too low) or two 1's, it might work
 
Back
Top Bottom