Which side of the coin are you on? | FinHeaven - Miami Dolphins Forums

Which side of the coin are you on?

DJRoss

Starter
Joined
Apr 28, 2007
Messages
215
Reaction score
1
Heads: Miami has a solid defensive secondary
Tails: Miami has a weak receiving corp

With so much focus on the QB battle, the question that could make a marked difference is whether the Dolphins are weak at receiver or strong at DB.

Reports during the early stages of training camp have told us that receivers are being jammed up on the line, taken out of their routes and dropping passes (could be stone hand syndrome or mental issues due to the DB's getting in their heads).

If you say Heads, than Miami may have a solid receiving corp with an outstanding secondary (meaning only those special start quality widouts are going to get any separation)

If you say tails, than we may have a situation where the DB's are at best mediocre and receivers (who didn't impress me last year, but that is only one opinion) who are just bad.

What happens when the intensity is raised and receivers need to deal with the possibility they will get laid out going across the middle. Do we see even more dropped passes?

Finally as an aside, how long will it take before the Oline gels enough to provide consistent protection. This is my biggest concern. Without this, who cares who is standing behind center throwing the ball as they will not perform at a high level with defenders constantly in their faces.

As for me I am leaning towards Tails. I am not sure, but what was lost last year in our less than stellar season, was the number of dropped passes by the receiving corp including Booker.
 
I say it's early and the defense is in front of the offense. The "D" better be good cause we're not gonna have any pass defense.
 
Let see how that secondary looks like when they play the Bucs this weekend. Then you can have an answer to your question. The DB's have only seen our WR. Lets watch this game coming up and see what happens.
 
Heads. The secondary is more experienced overall. Wilford is the WR with the most experience, and I haven't heard of him struggling at all in camp. Once the WRs learn how to get off a jam and get downfield, I'm pretty sure we'll see some improvements in the passing game. It seems that all the short stuff is there, it's just the long balls that aren't getting completed that often.
 
We have more and better veteran depth in the DB position. Still we can use an upgrade. As far as WR I beleive we are OK and will get better between Ginn and Hagan. I believe Bess, Foster and a one final veteran is all we need. Wether that veteran is Wilford is to be determined. Foster for speicail team is going to be kept around and will be the 5th. Ginn is good Hagan is getting there bess catches the ball. Still I could see Bess being bumped hopefully to the PS by Carmillio for this year as he bring help to ST that Bess does not.
Lets face it this team is built to run the ball and stop the run the passing game is secondary for the time being.
 
My side of the coin is the one that says "It's way too early to draw any conclusions".

The defense looked awesome at this time last year during camp and we all know what happened thereafter.
 
Since both are true, i'll actually flip a coin to see what the results are:

HEADS

clear.gif
 
We didn't make any improvements to the DB's and the only improvement to the recievers is Wilford. So I dont think were strong at either point.
 
I hate to say it but, I think our WR suck and our DB's are average to maybe slightly above average. Ginn and Hagan have potential but are extremely raw. Wilford has been a disappointment so far. Aside from Will Allen I doubt any of our other DB's will be on the roster 3 years from now, and maybe even he will be gone by then. Sorry, JMO. :(
 
i say that the secondary has a true leader and experienced guys and are lead by a guy Will Allen who should have been a pro bowler last year. Our wideouts have a 4th year guy a 3rd year guy and a 2nd year guy i think we have secondary player with more experience than all 3 of Ginn Wilford and Hagan combinded. If/when we get Glenn you WILL see a much better camp for your recievers his experience and leadership will be very beneficial and do us alot of good
 
Back
Top Bottom