Who has a better season: Beck or Henne? | Page 3 | FinHeaven - Miami Dolphins Forums

Who has a better season: Beck or Henne?

Who has a better season stat wise?

  • Total voters
    109
Miami has been awesome at picking loser QB's. Maybe our luck will change next year.
 
I think Beck,he has been training and working harder then any player in the league , His players even say the can see the fire in his eyes, I think Beck will be the QB like Bress, we let get away. And Shanahann is putting his reputation on the line in Beck. Joe Thiesman said he has been watching Beck and sees a different QB then the one that Played for the 1-15 dolphins.
 
Henne because he has a better team around him... But im sure Beck would beat out Henne.
 
I still remember watching Sunday Countdown in 2007, the week that Beck was taking over as a starter. Steve Young said he watched a lot of Beck in college (being his alma mater) and a lot of him in practice with the Dolphins. He said, using an alternative ranking system (I interpreted it as a football version of sabermetrics) that John Beck was in line with where Tom Brady was when he took over with the Pats.

Why wasn't he fired from ESPN after that year???
 
Honestly a lot of you have no idea. Sanchez is had identical stats and I don't see very many people (fans or media) making that known. Henne will be fine. Be a fan and stop sucking the media.
 
I root for Henne more than anyone. I hated the idea of booing him and I will be cheering loudly for him when he first steps on the field. I still think he's not a good quarterback.
 
Henne. He's got Marshall, Bess, Hartline, and Gates at WR, Fasano and Clay at TE, and it seems like a healthy OL, not to mention Reggie Bush and Daniel Thomas at RB.

Beck just sucks. You could put him on the 1984 49ers and he'd still find a way to **** it up.
 
You people have officially gone off the dep end. I can't believe this is a serious question and one that most of you on here are saying might be a close one. Are you kidding??? Beck?? This snowballing of the anti-Henne people is crazy. The guy has not even started for one full season while the Ryan Leaf's of the world got 5-6 years to prove if they had it or not. The guy got benched by a retard coach who didn't know how to handle not being succesfull at his Field Goal gameplan, and when he wasn't benched, he was being pulled out of the drive for a wildcat play right after completing a few passes in a row and getting momentum on our side. If you people didn't see that last year, you're crazy and lying to yourself. I was there for every game and it was a consistent trend. I can't blame the guy for having a difficult time adjusting

People on here are talking like if he's the worst QB in history. "Experts" are calling our free agency the worst of all teams because we didn't sign whoever to fix our "QB situation" but have nothing to say about Travaris Jackson being the starter in Seattle, or Derek Anderson in Carolina. It's sad how easily "fans" can be convinced to have the same beliefs as a sports reporter who uses his personal preference to make it sound as if it's just the way it is. If it's in the papers, it must be true right?? Think for yourself, and stop depending on these so-called experts to tell you how to feel about whichever player. People chanting for Orton??? Really?? teams can't wait to get rid of him, but he's our savior?? Get real............

I can't wait till Henne proves all of you wrong this year. Now go out there a prove me right Chad!! Go PHINS!! I can't wait till we get to crush the Patisies on MNF
 
We all better pray that the answer to this question is Chad Henne by a landslide...
 
My god 22 fans of John Beck.............:lol:
 
Granchamp71 said:
I still remember watching Sunday Countdown in 2007, the week that Beck was taking over as a starter. Steve Young said he watched a lot of Beck in college (being his alma mater) and a lot of him in practice with the Dolphins. He said, using an alternative ranking system (I interpreted it as a football version of sabermetrics) that John Beck was in line with where Tom Brady was when he took over with the Pats.

Why wasn't he fired from ESPN after that year???
Click to expand...

ESPN doesn't care about getting facts right, it's all about ratings.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Back
Top Bottom