Who was the better #55?

[Dolpfan_72]

This is a simple poll to see who people think has been the better number 55 on the Dolphins. By SO FAR I mean that I don't want people voting based on what they think Joey Porter might do or will become over the course of the next few seasons. I mean as of this very moment.

 

[fakespike]

i vote porter. seau was injured too much. not to mention porter nearly equaled seau's 3 year sack total (5) in one game. i remember seau making his share of good plays, but he missed 17 games in 2 years.

 

[Dolpfan_72]

That's a good point. I'm sure glad I listened to my gut feeling and didn't buy a Seau jersey.

 

[houtz]

Definitely Porter.

Other then with SD I always thought Seau was old and overrated.

 

[dolfan_germany]

I voted for Porter too.. Seau was getting old and was hurt too much but Porter is producing and still plays on a high level..

 

[Kadiddlehopper]

Lets wait until Joey's a dinosaur too before making the call.

 

[Dolphins12thMan]

This is a simple poll to see who people think has been the better number 55 on the Dolphins. By SO FAR I mean that I don't want people voting based on what they think Joey Porter might do or will become over the course of the next few seasons. I mean as of this very moment.

You should have added JT, that would of made it very interesting

 

[67Stang]

Seau was awful in pass coverage and outside persuit. I use to cringe if the back made the corner on the sweep.

 

[NJL52]

Not to mention that Seau loses a bunch of points for fake retiring and joining the Patriots.

Left a sour taste in my mouth.

 

[GoonBoss]

Between the two, Porter.

 

[Nappy Roots]

seau had a good first year, but injuries and age just caught up to him. joey has had a good 2nd year, but seaus first season was better then joeys first.

 

[SpaceMountain16]

It's an interesting question

Junior had a longer tenure here but was often injured. When he was healthy he played well at times but Joey has played excellent this season and very well the second half of last season. He's probably done more than Junior in his short time here. I guess i'll go JP. Even though i like Junior a lot better.

 

[PhinsPhan]

I'm sorry, did Seau do anything?

 

[SpaceMountain16]

I'm sorry, did Seau do anything?

The one year he got hurt and missed the season, i think it was against the Jets, he was having a great year.

 

[Dolpfan_72]

You should have added JT, that would of made it very interesting

You are very right. I didn't even think that way. I will redo this poll next week with JT and Zach Attack on it. :up: