Who would you rather have back Zach Thomas or Jason Taylor?

[ryanENGLISH0]

I know Zach signed with the Chiefs, but if both were available, I go with Taylor, i think he has more in the motor then Zach, but i wish they both would come back and play a couple more years with us.

 

[jonnyh]

Zach, all the way. JT is a better fotball player at this point. But Zach is a man, One of the truely great Dolphins of all time. Neither would offer alot on the field, but Zachs leadership would be far better than JT's. I don't think alot of the team would respect JT after last years Girl dancing.

 

[Lecanto]

I like Zach better as a person (nothing against Jason I like him too), but I think Jason has more left in the tank as a player. Zach has been undersized and got by on hustle his entire career, but that is much harder to do as you get older and the body doesn't hold up as well. Plus, Zach is undersized for this staffs’ size criteria. However, it is a mute point as Zach has signed with Kansas City.

 

[shula_guy]

neither

 

[maralieus]

Um Zach now plays for the Chiefs.

 

[BizarroAndres]

I dont think this is really fair, Taylor by a long shot. As everyone else has said, zach just doesnt have that much left.

 

[Ozfin77]

My heart says Zach, my head says JT.

 

[Blackcreekbandit]

i would say jason just because we have joey porter channing crowder and cam wake

 

[Dolphins7273]

Zach, all the way. JT is a better football player at this point. But Zach is a man, One of the truely great Dolphins of all time. Neither would offer alot on the field, but Zachs leadership would be far better than JT's. I don't think alot of the team would respect JT after last years Girl dancing.

And this is why it should be JT.

 

[Chubby]

I think at this point in their careers I would say JT would bring more value to the team then ZT would. I honestly dont know how much his 37 year old body is goign to be able to dish out or take.

If all the chips were the same though, you couldnt deny the value of having a great leader in the middle of our defense on the field. Can he relate to the 3-4? We will soon find out.
Chubbs

 

[tay0365]

This is a very tough question, I like them both, but I am a very big Zach fan, love his ability to anticipate what the other team will do, and never stops going. Miami needs more leaders, and Zach to me is a bit more of a leader (by action) then Jason.

 

[Boone]

neither.

 

[X-Pacolypse]

I'm shocked that it's this lopsided towards Jason.

 

[mcardenasd]

Zach All Day. He Is The Best Ilb In The League For Sure Two Years Ago, Now He Can Play Whit Crowder In The 3-4. Taylor Is A Machine, And A Good Bailarina, But He's Going To Stay In The Bench This Year For Dolphins.
Thomas

 

[Predaphin]

My heart says Zach, my head says JT.

exactly....

After what JT pulled on us last year, I like Zach better, but if you ask me who would I take right now, I gotta go with JT. It just seems JT has more left in the tank than Zach.