Who would you rather have?

[#1dolphinsfan]

would you rather have a 29 Year old Eric Parker or a 34 Year old Terry Glenn

I would much rather see us get Eric Parker rather then Terry Glenn and if we could get them both thats even Better then our WRs would look like

In no Particular order

Ted Ginn
Ernest Wilford
Derek Hagan
Eric Parker
Terry Glenn

 

[X-Pacolypse]

Terry Glenn. I'll pass on Eric Parker.

 

[phin2004]

Glenn is more proven, and still has some gas left in the tank if his knee holds up. Neither are a long term answer though.

 

[Canadianfishfan]

Glenn all the way.

 

[ccphinfan]

Of those two, a semi healthy Glenn

 

[WVDolphan]

I would take both of them, dump Hagan, and keep Kircus as the #5.

 

[clevelandm13]

Glenn for sure! I think we have enough unproven already.

 

[dolpns13]

a 75% healthy Glenn is far better than a 100% healthy Parker... Anyone who has sen Parker and Glenn play knows that

 

[TurkishFin99]

Glenn would bring in a little experience to the WR corps, which is something we could use.

 

[Tetragrammaton]

Can I select neither?

If I had to, Glenn. He is a trustworthy set of hands on third down. Ginn, Hagan, and Camarillo just aren't yet.

 

[poornate]

Glenn... absolutely...

 

[SarahAnn]

Can I select neither?

If I had to, Glenn. He is a trustworthy set of hands on third down. Ginn, Hagan, and Camarillo just aren't yet.

I agree with the neither but I disagree about Hagan, I hope he can step up and prove he can catch the ball. Ginn I just dont see being a very good WR.

 

[Avalanche of Wins]

I agree with the neither but I disagree about Hagan, I hope he can step up and prove he can catch the ball. Ginn I just dont see being a very good WR.

what about ginn leads you to such a conclusion? out of curiousity

 

[dolpns13]

I agree with the neither but I disagree about Hagan, I hope he can step up and prove he can catch the ball. Ginn I just dont see being a very good WR.

But you see Hagan being a better WR than Ginn? Although recieving stats are very comparable, Ginn outperformed Hagan immensly last year, and it doesnt take a Dolphin fan to see that Ginns hands are 100 times better than Hagans. In his first year as a rookie, Ginn "got it" as a reciever, whereas going into his third year, Hagan still does not.

 

[SpaceMountain16]

Terry Glenn, he may be older and coming off an injury but if he's healthy enough i think his age an experience is more valuable to a young team, especially experience with the Cowboys offense and working with Parcells and Ireland. Eric Parker has never done anything significant i dont see why anyone wants to sign him anyway.