Who'd You Rather Finish Out the Season: Moore or Cutler?

[SkapePhin]

Before Thursday, it seemed like the majority of posters wanted to hand the reigns over to Moore, myself included. After the horrific performance on TNF, it seems like the mood has changed. This poll is to get a sense of how people are thinking now...

I almost want to give Moore a pass because of the situation. TNF is almost always a bad game for the visiting team, and when you consider that the Ravens have always slaughtered the Dolphins, it was unreasonable to expect a great performance. But then again, he was real bad, even though the OL contributed.

Cutler is what he is, a broken down, uninspiring QB at this point, but perhaps he is a more steady option compared to Moore.

Who should be the starter?

 

[Mogwai]

The irony of a question like this is that either choice you make your season is already finished.

 

[<O>]

I was sold on Moore not long ago, but when the team looked just as uninspired with Moore against Baltimore, I think it's a wash at this point, and not a good one.

If the team is going to be just as uninspired with either one, I think you have to go with Cutler at this point, because he's demonstrated he's at least not going to lose games for you by throwing interceptions, whereas Moore has not.

And with this team's ineptitude on offense, it has to avoid turnovers at all costs, and try to allow the defense to keep it close so the offense can possibly pull it out in the end. INTs by the QB would ruin that.

 

[CammyCamCam]

Moore - Cutler has lost plenty of games in his career by throwing interceptions.

 

[randomname]

If I was making the decision, I would go with Moore next game.

But I really don't care anymore.

 

[Tiko377]

Cutler.

Just look at ATL game it was his biggest comeback of the year

Vs

Moore coming back against vs the Jets where they didn't study to play against him.

I hate how Moore usually predetermines where to go with the ball

 

[DefensiveEnd76]

Doesn't really matter because neither player is going to be with the Dolphins in 2018.

 

[maralieus]

Option C?

 

[Notso]

Tannehill in a wheelchair

 

[maralieus]

I was sold on Moore not long ago, but when the team looked just as uninspired with Moore against Baltimore, I think it's a wash at this point, and not a good one.

If the team is going to be just as uninspired with either one, I think you have to go with Cutler at this point, because he's demonstrated he's at least not going to lose games for you by throwing interceptions, whereas Moore has not.

And with this team's ineptitude on offense, it has to avoid turnovers at all costs, and try to allow the defense to keep it close so the offense can possibly pull it out in the end. INTs by the QB would ruin that.

Its hard to say if they were uninspired because they always get bullied by the ravens. We just got pushed around on both sides of the ball. Its the offensive line. It always has been. Always will be until they focus on it. Adam Gase better remember that quote "fool me once, shame on you, fool me twice, shame on me" as it relates to his believing the O-line can be coached up without talent. He tried twice and it failed twice. 3rd time and you're stubborn to a fault.

 

[3rd N Long]

Its hard to say if they were uninspired because they always get bullied by the ravens. We just got pushed around on both sides of the ball. Its the offensive line. It always has been. Always will be until they focus on it. Adam Gase better remember that quote "fool me once, shame on you, fool me twice, shame on me" as it relates to his believing the O-line can be coached up without talent. He tried twice and it failed twice. 3rd time and you're stubborn to a fault.

Gase did the same in Chicago, he knew his O-line was absolute garbage there and instisted he could work with the trash pile he was given, instead of asking for upgrades on the O-line. It's easily his worst attribute as a coach. Believing his coaching skill will help overcome a horrid O-line.

 

[DuderinoN703]

I’d rather be in a coma until free agency begins.

 

[Jimi]

Cutler still has a higher ceiling. Its not some giant conspiracy why Cutler has been a starter his whole career and Moore a backup. But at this point in their careers, the difference doesn't look like much. Cutler should start but it isn't going to change the team much either way.

 

[SCLSU Mud Dogs]

I’d rather be in a coma until free agency begins.

Yeah, shouldn't we have the technology available to cryogenically freeze ourselves until some point in the future? Those old shows and movies were too ambitious about the technology we'd have available in 2017.

 

[Fin Fan in Cali]

I think you have to go with Cutler and figure out how you are going to improve this position next year behind Ryan.