Who's Better to Finheaven?

[Charlie Rivers]

...with Cutler at the helm instead of Tannehill?

I feel that if Cutler remains free of injury, that we will roll easily into the championship games, and/or win one-of-the-two versus New England, or lose by a close score in one (or both even) Patriot/Dolphins matchups.

:eek:

 

[VBCheeseGrater]

I think its a wash, but could be wrong in either direction.

If held up at gunpoint to choose, id take Tannehill. Cutler has had more time to define himself, whereas i think tannehill was trending upwards

 

[Bumpus]

 

[finmann]

I would go with Tannehill.

 

[Charlie Rivers]

Would you say that Cutler will perform better on the field due to the change of seneary? I think being down here will spark something in him ... allowing him to play beyond his expectations. In everything, change is sometime that can benefit much, in some. Why not in Cutler?

Also, did Cutler not have success in Chicago because he was surrounded by a team that couldn't turn the corner ... (like Marino not winning a ring because of poor team around him). Now that he is in a much better system, and is already familiar with our schemes and such, will he make us shine?

 

[Adam Strange]

 

[nick1]

He's not in any way shape or form better then Tannehill

 

[Sarnics13]

 

[finmann]

Would you say that Cutler will perform better on the field due to the change of seneary? I think being down here will spark something in him ... allowing him to play beyond his expectations. In everything, change is sometime that can benefit much, in some. Why not in Cutler?

Also, did Cutler not have success in Chicago because he was surrounded by a team that couldn't turn the corner ... (like Marino not winning a ring because of poor team around him). Now that he is in a much better system, and is already familiar with our schemes and such, will he make us shine?

Cutler is a smart QB with a cannon for an arm with a don't care attitude, he is who he is. Maybe a change of scenery will do it for him, I really don't know, but as far am making us shine that's a long shot. Not to say it can't happen, but Cutler is not the long term answer for the Dolphins, he gets 10 million this year and should be gone when Tannehill comes back healthy. We can ill afford a QB controversy, the team belongs to Tannehill. Now when he comes back and god forbid he stinks up the joint then we can discuss bringing in another QB for the future. With all that being said, we should still draft a QB next year to groom.

 

[Avalanche of Wins]

A giant sinkhole opening up and swallowing foxboro mass.

 

[lurking]

I think your sig says it all.........

 

[finomenal]

...with Cutler at the helm instead of Tannehill?

I feel that if Cutler remains free of injury, that we will roll easily into the championship games, and/or win one-of-the-two versus New England, or lose by a close score in one (or both even) Patriot/Dolphins matchups.

:eek:

Huh? What? I got lost in your avatar.

 

[DANTODUPER]

...with Cutler at the helm instead of Tannehill?

I feel that if Cutler remains free of injury, that we will roll easily into the championship games, and/or win one-of-the-two versus New England, or lose by a close score in one (or both even) Patriot/Dolphins matchups.

:eek:

Neither one of those two is a top QB, or a game changer. As long as there are Ajayi and Landry out on the field with an average QB like Tannehill/Cutler we have possibility on the offensive side. If we somehow have a better Parker and solid play by the OL offense should be very fun to watch. But New England is in another league, just because they have elite level at the two crucial areas, coaching and QB. I do believe Gase can turn into an elite coach.

 

[Adam Strange]

This team isn't "rolling into the championship games" if mid-80s Dan Marino were behind center. The defense isn't good enough, to say nothing of the offensive line.

 

[Rolltide03]

This team isn't "rolling into the championship games" if mid-80s Dan Marino were behind center. The defense isn't good enough, to say nothing of the offensive line.

I mean we do look much better and deeper this year no?

Strictly talking defense