Why go Quinn, when we have culpepper and lemon? | FinHeaven - Miami Dolphins Forums

Why go Quinn, when we have culpepper and lemon?

Elle Clouds

Elle Clouds

Active Roster
Joined
Feb 14, 2006
Messages
2,408
Reaction score
852
I dont understand the need or want for Brady ...culpepper seems to be getting thrown under the bus...Quinn did not look NFL ready in their bowl game, and i have a feeling he will be an overhyped qb with performance issues. Im tired of having slow, immobile quarterbacks in Miami, so i think its time for a change. If we can not get Russell by trading up, I hope someone grabs quinn before we do.:rolleyes2
 
Why pay for health insurance when you are in perfect health? In the case of Culpepper nor Lemon panning out, we do have Quinn. Also a good QB is a hot commodity that can pay in dividends later. If Cleo proves himself to be a very accomplished passer and Quinn does the same, one of them could net us a very decent return in the trade market.

Not to mention, with the 9th pick we might as well go with best player available regardless of position (even if its a RB). I don't see many draftees at positions of need (like OT and CB) that are clearly worth a top 10 pick.
 
Quinn is the best QB in the draft, Culpepper has not played in two years and nobody knows if he will get healthy or regain his old form, chances are not great. I like Lemon, but you can't pin all your hopes on him.

If Quinn is at # 9, he will be a Fin.
 
NJFINSFAN1 said:
Quinn is the best QB in the draft, Culpepper has not played in two years and nobody knows if he will get healthy or regain his old form, chances are not great. I like Lemon, but you can't pin all your hopes on him.

If Quinn is at # 9, he will be a Fin.
Click to expand...


could u honestly say that Quinn looked better than Russell.. :goof: But i guess that is your opinion. Do you have any ties to Notre Dame?
 
daniel3 said:
Not to mention, with the 9th pick we might as well go with best player available regardless of position (even if its a RB). I don't see many draftees at positions of need (like OT and CB) that are clearly worth a top 10 pick.
Click to expand...
I 2nd that
 
NJFINSFAN1 said:
Quinn is the best QB in the draft, Culpepper has not played in two years and nobody knows if he will get healthy or regain his old form, chances are not great. I like Lemon, but you can't pin all your hopes on him.

If Quinn is at # 9, he will be a Fin.
Click to expand...
I certainly hope not. If Quinn falls to 9 though I think the Fins can get a nice package of picks.
 
Elle Clouds said:
I dont understand the need or want for Brady ...culpepper seems to be getting thrown under the bus...Quinn did not look NFL ready in their bowl game, and i have a feeling he will be an overhyped qb with performance issues. Im tired of having slow, immobile quarterbacks in Miami, so i think its time for a change. If we can not get Russell by trading up, I hope someone grabs quinn before we do.:rolleyes2
Click to expand...

You don't understand the need or want????

I see it like this: CP's return to PB form looks doubtful, JH is a good backup at best, and Lemon is unproven. Why WOULDN'T the Phins look to obtain a QB in the draft?
 
Elle Clouds said:
could u honestly say that Quinn looked better than Russell.. :goof: But i guess that is your opinion. Do you have any ties to Notre Dame?
Click to expand...
There are a lot of ND supporters and Brady Quinn supporters on this site. Be carefull knowcking Quinn though. It may just get you banned.:shakeno:
 
and this is all based on a feeling?

Elle Clouds said:
I dont understand the need or want for Brady ...culpepper seems to be getting thrown under the bus...Quinn did not look NFL ready in their bowl game, and i have a feeling he will be an overhyped qb with performance issues. Im tired of having slow, immobile quarterbacks in Miami, so i think its time for a change. If we can not get Russell by trading up, I hope someone grabs quinn before we do.:rolleyes2
Click to expand...

quinn had a bad bowl game and the other top quarterback in the draft just happened to be on the opposite sideline so therefore since russel won hes the better qb? how does one bowl game decide that? especially when quinn was facing a fast and well schemed lsu defense and russel was playing against a secondary that looked like "a bunch of ******s trying to hump a door knob".quinn has had a more successful career and he was developed in a pro style offense. his offensive line this year for notre dame really wasnt that good and the irish defense just plain stunk while russel enjoyed the satisfaction of having a team in lsu that could probably of beaten OURS right now:lol: Russel is athletic... but its not like hes coming in to be vince young, hes a PASSER, hes not gonna run for 60 yards especially with the speed the nfl has in it. Quinn is not slow and immobile and has shown it in his career too, he aint no mike vick, but his speed is supposedly in the 4.7-4.8 range (about the same as russel is believed to be).
 
Elle Clouds said:
I dont understand the need or want for Brady ...culpepper seems to be getting thrown under the bus...Quinn did not look NFL ready in their bowl game, and i have a feeling he will be an overhyped qb with performance issues. Im tired of having slow, immobile quarterbacks in Miami, so i think its time for a change. If we can not get Russell by trading up, I hope someone grabs quinn before we do.:rolleyes2
Click to expand...

LMAO

You're basing your opinion on 1 freaking game? Quinn has 2 years of experience under a pro style offense, I guess he's not ready because of 1 game:rolleyes:
 
Why Quinn, Becasue the fins have turned the other way for the QB postion in the draft since Marino left. Instead we get everybodys cast off. There is a resaon why these guys are being let go and dumped on the fins. They stink. It's time this franchise gets a big time QB in the draft that will be at the postion for years to come. This franchise has a turnover every year at QB. Thats why there has been no playoffs for years and horrible offensive playing. Harrington isn'rt the answer, C-pep and Lemon may or may not be the answer. If they aren't then the fins will again be looking at a qb turnover again. Get your stud now with Quinn.
 
Please, Please!!!

A stupid QB that can run and throw basic passes and look like a stud against college players and can probably never read an NFL defense.. Yes, I want Russelll!!!!:shakeno:

What I want is an NFL proto type QB, one who has been under Weiss and one who has the best potential to be a stud!!!!:ninja:


Not another Shuler, Leaf or Vick!!!!!:mad:
 
Last edited by a moderator:
You must log in or register to reply here.
Back
Top Bottom