Why wasn't Seth demoted? | FinHeaven - Miami Dolphins Forums

Why wasn't Seth demoted?

060693

Starter
Joined
Aug 1, 2004
Messages
141
Reaction score
0
He looked absolutely awful on Sat. Yet he was not demoted. I mean he was worth than Randy on Sat. but it's like he is made of teflon. Do you think Saban has a preference for Seth?
 
060693 said:
He looked absolutely awful on Sat. Yet he was not demoted. I mean he was worth than Randy on Sat. but it's like he is made of teflon. Do you think Saban has a preference for Seth?
There's no one better, that's the sad fact I think.
 
060693 said:
He looked absolutely awful on Sat. Yet he was not demoted. I mean he was worth than Randy on Sat. but it's like he is made of teflon. Do you think Saban has a preference for Seth?

I agree Seth has got to go :evil:
 
Hadnot couldn't do any worse than McKinney at C, but then we'd be in trouble at RG if Hadnot moved over....

McKinney is worthless IMO. He's the main reason our QB's get buried IMO....

PHINZ RULE!!!
 
Megatron said:
There's no one better, that's the sad fact I think.

and this is one of the big reasons why people like Pete Prisco thinks that there's a more realistic chance that hell will freeze over than the Fins actually making the playoffs this year.
 
KuchaMucha said:
and this is one of the big reasons why people like Pete Prisco thinks that there's a more realistic chance that hell will freeze over than the Fins actually making the playoffs this year.
I can't blame him for thinking that either.
 
BLITZKRIEG said:
but then we'd be in trouble at RG if Hadnot moved over....
how bout carey at RG and Dmac as our LT hoping hes healthy and ready to step it up
 
albyfinfan said:
how bout carey at RG and Dmac as our LT hoping hes healthy and ready to step it up


The problem then becomes RT. Stockar has been putrid (there's a reason that the Lions gave up on this guy). Not only has he had numerous mental lapses, he has flat out whiffed on assignments.

I agree that McKinney is a piece of garbage. I got sick of seeing his lazy *** get dominated last year. He absolutely sucks.
 
It's funny, I was under the impression that McKinney was demoted weeks ago. Wasn't there even an article stating Hadnot had moved ahead of McKinney during TC???....

Now he's back starting at C, and he's there to stay??? What the hell is going on here????...

PHINZ RULE!!!!
 
060693 said:
He looked absolutely awful on Sat. Yet he was not demoted. I mean he was worth than Randy on Sat. but it's like he is made of teflon. Do you think Saban has a preference for Seth?

Mcdougle sucks in a game and is demoted..mckinney has been sucking forever and hes not demoted.:lol:
 
BLITZKRIEG said:
It's funny, I was under the impression that McKinney was demoted weeks ago. Wasn't there even an article stating Hadnot had moved ahead of McKinney during TC???....

Now he's back starting at C, and he's there to stay??? What the hell is going on here????...

PHINZ RULE!!!!
A total lack of depth and talent on our O-line is what's happening.
 
34ibon99 said:
Mcdougle sucks in a game and is demoted..mckinney has been sucking forever and hes not demoted.:lol:

Sad but true....

McKinney has been dominated his entire career. Where's Tim Ruddy when we need him???...

Later....
 
BLITZKRIEG said:
Sad but true....

McKinney has been dominated his entire career. Where's Tim Ruddy when we need him???...

Later....

Give thanks to Spielman for that. Got rid of Ruddy and handed the reins to McKinney...and was so in love with him that he gave up another third round draft pick the next year for his college teammate, Taylor Whitley! :fire:
 
Hadnot blew a lot of calls at center in the game he played. To play center he'd need the entire training camp.
 
LT- Vernon Carey
LG- Jeno James
C- Rex Hadnot
RG- Frank Middleton
RT- Stockar McDougle

That is what I hope to eventually see as our starting Offensive line. If Stockar McDougle CANNOT pan out which I haven't given up on, move Carey to RG, McIntosh to LT, and Middleton RT

LT- D-Mac/Vernon Carey
LG- Jeno James
C - Rex Hadnot
RG- Vernon Carey/D-Mac
RT- Frank Middleton/Stockar McDougle (if benched)

Of course you can see the lineup gets extremely confusing with moving people around, but I feel that Seth McKinney does not belong in the starting lineup, definitely not at C. I like the first lineup I mentioned, and that's what I feel will benefit us the best and I trust Coach Houck's judgement regardless.


LT- Vernon Carey
LG- Jeno James
C- Rex Hadnot
RG- Frank Middleton
RT- Stockar McDougle

Three guys that I expect to be in the starting lineup for other no matter what, is Carey, Hadnot, and McDougle (and yes I've always thought very highly of him despite him being considered an underachiever). If Middleton ends up in the starting lineup whether it's at RG, RT, or LG... it will take time for it to happen for him to get adjusted to the system. Jeno James, I think will be in the starting lineup unless injury and health concerns get in the way. There's no doubt in my mind our O-line is going to be much better than last year and it's going to take some time for them to gel together and function successfully as a team... I like the improvement that's been made on the pass protection but I anticipate better and hope for them to be a solid unit and to unify a well established solid running back. I unlike many others here aren't panicking over the way this preseason has been going, I've actually been impressed by quite a few things as well as concerned with quite a few things as well. I'm a strong believer in an offensive line being the focal point of an offense, and I do feel that we are headed in the right direction with our coaching staff and personnel. First things first though, give Rex some more playing time at C (only wish that we did that a lot earlier, especially in Training Camp) and seat Seth. It's definitely going to take time since Rex has been playing RG for most of TC. But I feel that we're better off Rex learning to be a good C rather than depending upon Seth, that's just my personal opinion.
 
Back
Top Bottom