Worst Dolphins QB Ever? Most hated? Lets be thankful!

[Phinfan31]

Maybe not everybody is convinced in Tannehill...but tell me you would rather have ANY of these guys!?

Lmao....

All things considered - who was the WORST QB who ever donned a Dolphins uniform?

This might seem like an easy answer, but IMO its not...

First - Honorable mentions - RAY LUCAS...omfg...I'll never forget when he threw a pass up STAIGHT up in the air in one of our last games of the season....smh. Sad thing is he was really injured. A.J. Feeley/Cleo Lemon are also up there...but Feeley gave us the memory against the Pats on MNF...and Cleo saved our season from being winless with that pass to Camarillo against the Ravens.

My vote:

Daunte Culpepper. It was a toss up with the likely #1 worst/most hated player on the list - Ray Lucas. But IMO this stung more...Lucas was never supposed to start. We traded a 2nd rounder for Culpepper OVER Drew Brees FFS....and he was complete and utter garbage. Yes...Lucas owns the worst statistics in a single game by a Dolphin QB ever...and he single handedly destroyed what could have been a deep playoff run in 2002...but the thing is...I thought we would continue to be a winning team. I thought we would be back to greatness soon enough. It hurt but I was able to move on.

With Culpepper though...after he/Saban left we descended into the darkest of times in Dolphins history.

NOW...HOW HAPPY are you that we have Ryan Tannehill after re-living some of these memories of horror? Haha.

 

[greasyObnoxious]

well, it never gets old, but....

Damon Huard
Jay Fiedler
Ray Lucas
Brian Griese
A.J. Feeley
Gus Frerotte
Sage Rosenfels
Joey Harrington
Daunte Culpepper
Cleo Lemon
Trent Green
John Beck
Chad Pennington
Chad Henne
Tyler Thigpen
Matt Moore

let that sink in for a minute. Pennington had a very good year, Frerotte and Matt Moore had some success, but besides, it's hard to pick a "worst" QB out of that group.

 

[cafinfan408]

Culpepper for most hated mayyybe.. i dont blame him for being over hyped and hurt.
Worst qb to actually get multi starts is probably John Beck the kid could not get out of his own way... I understand picking Lucas though
Pat While damn near died on the field after showing nothing.
Trent green was bad for us joey harrington was mostly bad for us.

 

[72 silky]

Feeley, remember when he hurt is butt/hammy and was running around like a fool lol

 

[Daytona Fin]

Scott Stankavage

 

[Wildbill3]

Lucas.

 

[FinfanInBuffalo]

Lucas for single handedly destroying a season.

 

[fininpsl]

He ultimately never played a game for the Phins, but David Garrard belongs in the poll because he was such a bad signing.

 

[AXAFinFan]

Lucas for single handedly destroying a season.

My vote goes to Lucas hands down. I think he had more pick 6's than td passes!

 

[DolFan in NE]

That list looks and smells like a used diaper.

 

[hoops]

My vote goes to Lucas hands down. I think he had more pick 6's than td passes!

well if you listen to a Wendy's dairy dessert he and tannehill are equals

 

[AXAFinFan]

well if you listen to a Wendy's dairy dessert he and tannehill are equals

No one can equal Lucas... he's in a class all by himself!

 

[doughbraz54]

**** John Beck.

 

[Eesti]

Those guys are pale in comparison to the guys who hired them.

 

[Vol&dolfan]

Gotta be Spray Mucas.