worst free agent signing this year | FinHeaven - Miami Dolphins Forums

worst free agent signing this year

worst free agent pick up

  • Total voters
    242
amir7

amir7

Seasoned Veteran
Joined
Jun 11, 2005
Messages
721
Reaction score
1
Location
fairfax VA
which of the free agents we sighned this year have so far been the most dissapointing
 
now to think about it they were all pretty good. Kevin Carter has been the best, and is the most underrated on the defense i think. Mcdougle has probably been the worst though
 
Im still ticked at Ephraim for that penalty against the Bills so I'll say him. I dont think any of our signees have been very dissapointing though. I was expecting more out of Spragan but since I never watched him play prior to signing with us, I wont be too hard assessing him. Traylor has been my favorate pick up with Shulters in 2nd.
 
Easy. It's Stockar. He won't be here next year.
 
Simmer Finner said:
tebucky jones has been a bad signing , the guy has done nothing...
Click to expand...

Wrong....he's one of the only guys in our secondary that can actually tackle. He made a key stop on McGahee in a big goal line stance and he also had a sack and I believe is 2nd on the team in tackles. He may not be a huge playmaker but imo he has played pretty solid.
 
I owuld have to say

1)Stockar
2)Spraggan
3)Frerotte

The rest have been solid for us.
 
well, i cant call any of those signings "BAD", cus its all about how much they are paid, and how much they add to the team, and how much was expected of them.

i thaught McDougle was your best signing in the offseason. but his performance has not be what i thaught it would be. so in my book, he has gone from best to worse pickup.
 
Really I think we did a great job in signing all these guys. They all are pretty much stopgaps but they still served a purpose. I think the McDougle signing was worth taking a chance on, even though he hasn't played that well.
 
mcdougle without a doubt. he has done nothing for our oline yet this season.
i think the best is schulters he is the only one in the secondary that is keeping us from get blown away in the passing game
 
McDougle, with Spragan a close second.
 
FakeSpike13 said:
Spragan, stockar frerrotte, in that order...
Click to expand...


That also would be my order as well. Spragan hasn't did a damn thing!!! Stockar is good when he doesn't get called for a false start or holding(which happens 65% of the time). Most of the sacks or huried passes are coming from the left side or up the middle(probably due to the best DE play on that side or the LB blizting up the middle). Yes Stockar could get better on his pass protection but for a running game...he can get the job done.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Back
Top Bottom