Would you continue to dog?

[The Borg]

The QB position is so polarizing at the moment...I'm curious.

Those of you who are dogging Beck right now..."IF" he was to start this year, have a solid year and lead the Dolphins admirably and to a winning season...would you still contiue to dog him? Or, would you cut the guy some slack and admit he's a decent athelete?

 

[Charlie Brown]

I think some people on here are almost rooting aginst him....which makes me wonder why are they even Dolphin fans?.....rooting aginst your QB is like rooting aginst your team.

 

[Mogwai]

Strange question. Would the people who dog Beck for his lack of production continue to dog him if he actually produced? Hmm. I can't imagine they would unless there is rabid anti-Mormon sentiment on this board.

 

[sleek]

I like McCown best but I wouldn't dog Henne or Beck. I like all three. I will support who ever wins the job and I think they are all working hard to improve. Also a plus they are all healthy so we don't have to worry about them being limited due to injuries.

 

[phinphever]

I want all of these guys to excell. But, I am hopeing one of the steps up.

 

[WelcomeBack]

I know who I WANT to win the QB competition, but I will continue to cheer whoever wins it in hopes that they do a solid jobs.

I WANT Henne to win the competition, but I don't dog Beck. I just hope whoever wins the starting job will succeed.

 

[Duriel]

It's nice to see some fans here (probably most) realize we should be hoping everyone on the roster does well.

 

[WelcomeBack]

It's nice to see some fans here (probably most) realize we should be hoping everyone on the roster does well.

Well, I'm sure that the majority are hoping the team does well. But at the same time, that leads to the argument of who can lead the team to do well.

Some people have the indifference of opinion on Beck and Henne and who they feel can actually lead this team to success. I personally feel that person is Henne, but I'd rather point out all of Henne's positives rather than John Beck's negatives.

People just take different approaches to their arguments.

 

[Elliott 1]

Yes, fumbleina is not Dolphin material and never should have been drafted.

The Dolphins should have traded him yesterday for a good OT.