Would you Ditka 2012 draft for luck or another qb | FinHeaven - Miami Dolphins Forums

Would you Ditka 2012 draft for luck or another qb

NJPHINFAN79

NJPHINFAN79

Active Roster
Joined
Sep 3, 2009
Messages
1,618
Reaction score
737
Location
Jersey
Trade all ur picks to move up and pick first if its an option, remember the number one money is not such a negative anymore... just curious, have at it...
 
No. Luck is not the only good QB and as has been proven in other QB heavy drafts, often times the first one taken is not the best (Tim Couch anyone?). Also, look at all the QB's drafted ahead of Marino in 1983.
 
I don't know if I'd give up 2 drafts for luck, but I'd give up one. I'd swap firsts and give up a second and 4th for Barkley.
 
Depends where we end up, if we are at 15 or 16 with no shot at landing Luck, Barkley or Jones I would consider maybe not all our picks but trading the farm for Luck. If we are in the mid to late 20s there is no need because clearly Henne stepped up
 
Without hesitation I would trade everything for Luck. That includes however many picks, any player already on our team, heck I'd throw my mom in as well.
 
If Luck and Barkley look good this upcoming season and offseason? Absolutely.

This past decade has shown that if you do not have a quarterback you do not have a winning team.
 
If Luck was definately the next Marino/Manning/Elway etc def.. But i'm not sure how good or bad the rest of the QB's coming out next year are.. Everything you read is its going to be a deep QB class. Then you say to yourself what teams besides us need a QB? SF, Sea, Oak, maybe Buf?
 
I can't even believe what my answer is to this because I always thought it was STUPID, STUPID, STUPID, to trade an entire draft+ for any one player, but.... If Henne sucks this year and the team is still sitting around .500 and no playoffs then that means the team is good but DESPERATELY needs a QB so yes I would go to very desperate measures to attain one. I think the team has just as much talent and good players as the Packers do, but the difference is... they have a stud QB and Miami does not so like I said do whatever you have to to get Luck or whoever is the best QB in the draft next year(If Henne doesn't take a major leap forward this season)
 
I'd basically givee up anything for Luck - he's the next Peyton.
 
Luck makes us an instant playoff team and real contender. This is a no brainer. All the stupid F'ed up picks we made over the last decade, PLEASE trade 7 picks in 2012 for our franchise QB. Our D is pretty young and more than solid. Get a TE in FA - DONE and DONE, See you in the AFC Championship game on the way to the Super Bowl.
 
Luckily the QB class next year is very very good, pun not intended. If Miami takes a first rounder, I think they'll be in good shape no matter where they draft at, unless something crazy happens and 7QBs come off the board in the first 15 picks.
 
It's no coincidence that Ditka was fired 8 1/2 months after he did this. No thanks.
 
Depends if Luck has a good year without Harbaugh. Remember Harbaugh is supposed to be a QB guru. Luck has all the talent in the world, but let's see if he can do it with a different coach.
 
TPD1479 said:
If Luck was definately the next Marino/Manning/Elway etc def.. But i'm not sure how good or bad the rest of the QB's coming out next year are.. Everything you read is its going to be a deep QB class. Then you say to yourself what teams besides us need a QB? SF, Sea, Oak, maybe Buf?
Click to expand...

I don't think SF would be looking for a QB as their letting Alex Smith go into this season and if he doesn't pan out they will use kaepernick. And Oakland shouldn't be looking for a QB Campbell is an ok QB and they already overpaid for him might as well run with him. And the team that will probably be looking for a QB the most next year is probably Washington, Beck or Grossman? Pick your poison, I think they'll have the best shot at luck.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Back
Top Bottom