Would you trade Gesicki?

[Carne Asada]

IMO it'd be best if we schemed the first few games to showcase Gesicki and then traded him before the deadline. Trade him at his highest value. Week 5 with 400 yards and 2-3 TDs for a first round pick would be ideal. That would be 6 picks in the top 100, 4 in the top 60 and 3 in the first round. Having said that if anyone offers a first at any point, I'd send him.

 

[John813]

if he has 400 yards and 3 tds by week 5 you keep him cause that’s an impact player at TE.

 

[BC Phins4Life]

Agreed @John813, looks like we are putting together quite a good team with some star pieces and hopefully MG is right there when they do challenge in the playoffs.

 

[Carne Asada]

if he has 400 yards and 3 tds by week 5 you keep him cause that’s an impact player at TE.

While that certainly makes sense he's on the tag and he can't block, he's just a large slot receiver. You could say he's our #3, not Wilson. You could scheme some production for him in the first few games to increase his value, though.

 

[MrChadRico]

Only way I trade him is if his run blocking is so bad it's preventing him from playing most of the running plays.

If he can block even mediocre I would try to extend him.

 

[Rockchalk]

First off the answer to the question "Would you trade <player>?" is almost always 'yes' if the deal is extremely advantageous. That said I don't think you move what could be a big weapon for your young QB. The Hill, Waddle, Gesicki trio has a chance to be elite.

 

[Marino1313]

Of course if the price is right

 

[jimthefin]

The only sensible reason to trade him is if he is having a great year and has real trade value.

If that is happening you keep him because it is good to have players on your team who are having good years. I have heard that kind of thing helps you win.

Now if he is putting up numbers but the team is struggling maybe you move him for a draft pick ahead of letting him walk as a FA(assuming they don't want to pay him).But you would have to get a better pick than the comp you would receive for losing him in FA.The Fins are not going to be spending big next FA season so they would surely get a comp 3rd rounder for him.

 

[1972forever]

I wouldn’t trade him at this time.He is a positive influence on the team because of his ability and his attitude. You never heard him complain at all when he was franchised and everything he says is positive in regards to his teammates and the coaches.

While his ability to be an effective blocker in the McDaniel system certainly appears to be an issue. I believe MCDaniel and the offensive coaches will find a way to use Gesicki and his skill set to maximize his effectiveness.

His future in Miami will be determined by his contract demands after the 2022 season and the development of Long during the 2022 season. Personally I hope Gesicki is a Miami Dolphin for several years beyond the 2022 season. So I wouldn’t trade him unless another team just makes them an offer too good to refuse.

 

[Miami4471]

The question I would ask is would Kansas city trade Kelce if he had 400 yards, some how I don't think so. If he's got that many yards he's Tua's go to guy

 

[BennySwella]

I just don't know why we have so many TEs if we're going to move forward with him.

He is our best catching TE by far, and our worst blocking TE by far. If we are going to play 2 tight ends sets we keep him, if not, trade him.

Personally would like to see him extended for a reasonable contract. Nothing near top TE money. 4 year 40 mil... 21 mil guaranteed.

 

[Carne Asada]

I just don't know why we have so many TEs if we're going to move forward with him.

He is our best catching TE by far, and our worst blocking TE by far. If we are going to play 2 tight ends sets we keep him, if not, trade him.

Personally would like to see him extended for a reasonable contract. Nothing near top TE money. 4 year 40 mil... 21 mil guaranteed.

We may be going with 21 personnel. Smythe as the actual TE and Gesicki on the slot. I'd rather see those two on the field than Wilson.

 

[Tuaffinity and Beyond]

Give him this year to work on blocking. If at the end of the year it’s the same as the beginning then you trade.

 

[fin007]

IMO it'd be best if we schemed the first few games to showcase Gesicki and then traded him before the deadline. Trade him at his highest value. Week 5 with 400 yards and 2-3 TDs for a first round pick would be ideal. That would be 6 picks in the top 100, 4 in the top 60 and 3 in the first round. Having said that if anyone offers a first at any point, I'd send him.

Nope. I would trade last years Oline. All of them.

 

[Michael Scott]

If he fits within the scheme and makes a high impact then it’s a no brainer to extend him.

We are no longer a rebuilding team. The days of building up a player to trade him for picks should be over with.