Gotta think Knicks fans and members of the FO are pissed. They were sold on how they'd clear up as much space as possible and that they would get 2 max level players. I know I really hated how a lot of New York people acted pbecause all I heard is ""how can anybody turn us down? We're New York!". And I honestly think Amar'e went to New York under the assumption another max guy was coming.
While getting Felton, Amare, Randolph, and Turiaf make them a better team (with Randolph having the potential to be a VERY good player) their starting lineup will probably be...
PG-Felton
SG-Chandler
SF-Gallinari
PF-Randolph
C-Amare
with Douglas and Turiaf off the bench
While that team may be fun to watch, there is absolutely no defense on that team. Teams like Orlando, Milwaukee, Chicago, Boston, Miami (no matter who they put out there with the Triad, LeBron and Wade are good defenders), and Atlanta (not great defenders outside of Smith and Horford, but a long athletic team that would give teams problems) will kill them. Hell even Toronto, which has sucked at defense for a couple years, have discovered some young guys who are very good defenders (Amir Johnson, DeMar Derozan, Sonnie Weems, potentially Soloman Alabi and Ed Davis)
And how will Amare do without Nash? I know Felton isn't a scrub starter like Chris Duhon, but the MJ/Larry Brown regime loves DJ Augustine and you don't just let good PGs walk.