This is taking me some thinking time. Could be the hardest challenge to judge like jt said. Both of youdid great work this time :yes:
1.
Positives: I like the background on this looks good. I also like the player render. His lighting looks great on this background, really good job with that. Text is also a good color. Good choice of pic.
Negatives: Not a big deal, but I'm not positive I like the 3 and the 5.
Overall: 4.7/5
2.
Positives: The Timberwolves logo looks great for this type of sig. Great job with the text cause it looks great. I like the idea of the swoosh by the ball.
Negatives: I think tha ball swoosh would look better if it was orange. Something just looks a little off with it. I think it would also look a little better if a jersey switch was done, even though I'm sure it would have been hard.
Overall: 4.5/5