Personally, I think Jay is a slightly above average quarterback. He is not good enough to consistently win games on his own, but it is hard to argue the fact that he has almost single-handedly won some games himself (anyone remember, for example, the 2001 game in Buffalo? Or how about the home game against Carolina that year, with swirling winds and Lamar Smith getting stuffed at the line, Jay threw for almost 300 yards, if I remember correctly). Jay's biggest problems are a lack of consistency, and a lack of superior athletic ability, and he has been able to make up for those with heart and determination on the field to win a lot of games the last four years. Has the defense won a lot of games for him? Sure. Has he lost some games for the team? Yes. Regardless of how much the defense helps him or whatever, you simply do not suck if you are at the helm of as many wins as Jay has been. I'm not a "Fiedler Hugger", nor am I a hater. I'm just pretty sure that we've seen the best Jay brings to the table. He's a quarterback good enough to get the Dolphins to 10-11 wins, and into the play-offs, but I don't think he's good enough to go all the way. Personally, I would love to see A.J. light it up this summer and take over in the fall, because obviously the team would improve. But if we're stuck with Jay at quarterback, we could do worse. I'm just hoping that A.J. proves to be better, thus making the whole team better.
:tongue: