RUDEbyallMEANS said:McMichael doesn't deserve any "love" yet.
He needs to earn it before being given it.
IMO, Most overrated on Miami but the best cheerleader.
RUDEbyallMEANS said:McMichael doesn't deserve any "love" yet.
He needs to earn it before being given it.
IMO, Most overrated on Miami but the best cheerleader.
How was Shockey horrid last year? 48 catches in 9 games. The only reason people think he had a bad year was because he didn't get any extra attention for running his mouth.Jimmy James said:I think Gonzo and Heap are no brainers, but the others can't be ahead of Randy IMHO.
Crumpler hasn't done anything more than Randy has. I'd put them about even.
Shockey had a horrid year last year and didn't show that much his rookie season. Come back when he shows it.
The same goes double for Winslow. He might be far better, but he needs to show it in the NFL first.
Edit: To be clear, I'm saying that Shockey's first year wasn't so special that it makes up for a really subpar sophomore season. Players are supposed to progress, not regress, between years 1 and 2. Until he either matches the rookie performance or shows substantial improvement from year 2, he gets no love from me.
LIQUID24 said:How was Shockey horrid last year? 48 catches in 9 games. The only reason people think he had a bad year was because he didn't get any extra attention for running his mouth.
McMichael had 49 catches in 16 games.
Sorry, but Mcmike is not in Shockey's class quite yet.
I'd take Shockey, Winslow, Crumpler, Gonzo, & Heap over McMichael any day of the week.