Mcmichael's Stupidity In Calling 911....drew Cant Believe It.

[dolfanreal69]

Yeah they have been a winning team for the past 3 years and have nothing to be ashamed of!

 

[DoLpHiNz34]

Let me add something here cus i am taking business law and i have stuff right in front of me here on assault and battery:

Here goes: first off, Randy is the plaintiff here and not the defendant. She hit him, that is Assault and Battery. key here is the defendant INTENTIONALLY MAKES CONTACT.

Defenses to Assault and Battery
Consent- If an individual consents to an A/B, there is generally no liability for the harm done.
Self defense- If an individual commits A/B while defending himself, he can claim self defense
DEfense of others- if an idividual who commits A/B based on reasonable belief that someone is being injured, he can claim defense of others (she was pregnant)
DEfense of property- reasonable force can be used in protecting one's home, however substantial bodily harm or death is generally not allowed.


So as you see, it is more his wife that is under fire here more than randy. Randy simply came home drunk and she took out her frustration by hitting him and i imagine more than once. Im sure randy was covering up until he pushed her (this is my imagination of how things transpired). He realized the situation he was in and that he could be in trouble so he calls 911 to make it record that he called for help (really pretty damn smart if you ask me being who he is).
Now if something happens to that baby then RM would be in deep doo doo. But if all he did was push her in self defense and called 911, then she is the one who lossed her cool and commited the battery, not RM. And it sounded to me like she was hesitant in saying that he actually hit her instead of just pushing her. A good lawyer would punch holes in that all day and i am sure she will come to her senses and realise she went off and overboard simply cus he came home drunk. I wonder if Claire ever did that to Dan when he came home from a Druer's binge?

I'm glad to see that you're going to law school cause you nailed this one on the head. I agree with you 100%. Everyone that's ripping him for calling the cops is just being ignorant. What else should he have done? Go listen to the call it's in another thread. He says it himself..."please get me and my kid outta here(like 30 times) I'm about to knock this *beep* out"...He realized he was going to lose his cool and called the cops. Not to mention he's friggin RANDY MCMICHAEL, he was hit first, he was drunk, she's pregnant, and he was throwing up! One last point, if he was really trying to beat her or anything different than what is reported to have happen why would he call the cops?

 

[DoLpHiNz34]

say goodbye to randy mcmicheal in a fins uniform .... look for miami to re-evaluate his position with the team after the season ... and quit possibly bring in a few TE's during next years F/A period ... and possibly in the 2005 draft

You're insane

 

[Ozzy]

No, you grab her and hold her, or you try and get the weapon from her. You don't hit her. What the hell is up with that?

..and some people wonder why they can't get a none(not really directed at a single person). :shakeno:

NEVER HIT A WOMAN!!! Just shake the %%%% out of her until you hear marbles!!

:roflmao:

 

[yankeehillbilly]

......... One last point, if he was really trying to beat her or anything different than what is reported to have happen why would he call the cops?

I suspect that if he was really trying to beat her she would have a lot more than a bruised arm and slight swelling in her cheek.

 

[ohall]

That's just like some of the folks dissing Moore's movie that's not even seen it yet, ya??

Yeah, well I wish I had hit Michael Moore then I could see your point.

And no, unlike this incident there are factual quotes from the movie, and movie clips that give anyone a good insight into what Moore is pushing.

Oliver...

 

[ohall]

Yeah, I suppose you'd say that if one of those roided out weight lifting bimbos was giving you the beat down of your life.

LIES LIES! THOSE ARE NOT WOMEN!

OMG!

Oliver...

 

[ohall]

NEVER HIT A WOMAN!!! Just shake the %%%% out of her until you hear marbles!!

:roflmao:

LoL, that's just wrong!

Oliver...

 

[DoLpHiNz34]

I suspect that if he was really trying to beat her she would have a lot more than a bruised arm and slight swelling in her cheek.

Precisely.

 

[Dolfan954]

When is the last time you ever heard of a 6'3 250 pound football player dialing up 911 on his wife....after a slap across the face...? And this is a very pettite 21 year old woman. This is an absolute joke...I saw Drew last night....and he is now aware that any thoughts this year of extending Mcmichaels contract are virtually now....non-existent. This situation could of and should of...of course been handled within the Mcmichael household. For Randy...calling 911 himself...this was really a cardinal type of error. This is going to be a Derrick Rogers situation all over again....and you know when ROGERS came back to the team after the incident....the players and coaching staff...knew that he was distracted...and his play also showed that. The media now is going to be all over this situation throughout training camp...and with the offense not even on the same page already...and with RANDY a huge part of it....this situation is now playing out for the unknown. This is the type of behavior that the DOlphins really do not condone...zero tolerence policy on domestic abuse....and they already have Security Director STU WEINSTEIN all over the police reports...as his job with the DOlphins....is to follow up on all of this...get the reports...and keep the NFL Security offices up to date on the matter at hand. Obviously....if the state Attorneys office files charges....there is going to be a very dark cloud over RANDY....and a suspension from the league office is sure to follow. Drew is going to meet with this attorney--SWICKLE and RANDY tommorrow....and you can bet the ranch and the outpost....that there is going to be some major down-playing spin control on this matter...but the bottom line is that BOTH spouses have been charged....meaning that there was credible evidence that Randy was hit pretty hard....so what does he do....he hits her back...and then he is still coherent enough to pick up the phone...dial 911 and cry for help. All the coaching and warning in the world on domestic violence....and even Drew or any agent now goes over and over the dangers of domestic disputes getting out of hand...and the one phrase that they all tell there clients....NEVER STRIKE A WOMAN....no matter what the dispute is...no matter what happens....NEVER DO IT. And our stating TE....the one who wants more money? What does he end up doing? He just struck himself out of any contract extension....he may end up doing time...and at the very least...he is looking at a league suspension. This situation will linger on well past training camp...that you can be assured of...and now the coaches have to be really shaking there heads on the what if situations---especially if RANDY is consumed by this. And now...how will he be looked at now? By the players and the coaches? Do they support him? Do they look the other way? Wanny was teed off on this...and now what does he do....does he look at more at TES JOHN JONES and DONALD LEE...does he give them more of a look..now...if you are the offensive coaches.....what are you thinking about this guy? This is all your going to be reading about for the next few days....get used to the spin....because its coming and Drew is hoping that both the Mcmichaels will come out tommorrow or at this point...today....and tell the world that they are both sorry...and that they would like to begin counseling....that they will work this out. Thats the only negotiation Drew will be discussing with Mcmichael....and of course....the other attorney. As the WORLD....check that....AS THE DOLPHINS TURN WILL CONTINUE after these local messeges....

Is there evidence that he hit her back though? Just because the police came and charged both of them doesn't necessarily mean that he hit her. He's actually lucky they didn't both go to jail that night.

If the cops have to come to the house for a domestic dispute, someone is usually going to end up going to jail that night. It could have been as simple as:

His wife got mad and hit him, and he DIDN'T do anything, locked himself in a room, and dialed 911. I don't remember hearing a woman screaming during the call, so it's possible. I'm with you on the stupidity of it, DCH. I remember watching the news and hearing the 911 call thinking, "What the hell was he thinking? Doesn't he know calling the police will only bring charges?" Then again, he probably wasn't thinking straight since he was drinking.

 

[Dolfan954]

:shakeno: :shakeno: :shakeno: no matter what don't hit the lady she can be screaming slapping you around and the whole nine.. get up and leave the house....... let her calm down... discuss the issue in the morning when all of the anger is clear...

man the Fins are having a rough OFF SEASON.....

I don't believe in hitting women either; however....

Just because men aren't supposed to hit women doesn't give women the golden pass to hit men. Two adults should be able to iron out an issue without resorting to physical violence.

 

[WharfRat]

Is there evidence that he hit her back though? Just because the police came and charged both of them doesn't necessarily mean that he hit her. He's actually lucky they didn't both go to jail that night.

If the cops have to come to the house for a domestic dispute, someone is usually going to end up going to jail that night. It could have been as simple as:

His wife got mad and hit him, and he DIDN'T do anything, locked himself in a room, and dialed 911. I don't remember hearing a woman screaming during the call, so it's possible. I'm with you on the stupidity of it, DCH. I remember watching the news and hearing the 911 call thinking, "What the hell was he thinking? Doesn't he know calling the police will only bring charges?" Then again, he probably wasn't thinking straight since he was drinking.

Actually... just to clarify... they did both end up in jail....

 

[WharfRat]

I don't believe in hitting women either; however....

Just because men aren't supposed to hit women doesn't give women the golden pass to hit men. Two adults should be able to iron out an issue without resorting to physical violence.

:up: Exactly

 

[NCFINFAN38]

NEVER HIT A WOMAN!!! Just shake the %%%% out of her until you hear marbles!!

:roflmao:

NO!!!!! You just grab her and let her go...........over the edge of the 14 story balcony. :roflmao: :roflmao: :roflmao:

 

[DoLpHiNz34]

. He's actually lucky they didn't both go to jail that night.

Umm....they did.