Zim's Grades For The Game: Week 5 Edition | FinHeaven - Miami Dolphins Forums

Zim's Grades For The Game: Week 5 Edition

DZimmer000

BJJ Black Belt
Super Donator
Club Member
Joined
Aug 9, 2005
Messages
4,222
Reaction score
10,840
Wanna know what's scary? Tua was off yesterday, and we still hung 31 points and a 500 + yards on another NFL team. That's scarier than my ex-girlfriend waking up in the morning without her makeup on. Obviously, it was a game we should have won.... And we did. But...What I really liked is how we won it anyway we needed to. Also, it's nice to see the Bills lose and put us all alone in first again. On to the grades:

QB -- B : As I mentioned earlier, Tua was off yesterday. The pick-6 was a really bad decision. As a matter of fact... there were 3 defenders around Waddle when he threw that ball. If we were playing a good team....That might have cost us the game. The other pick, I think Tua tried to stop the throw midway through his motion, but it was too late. The long bomb to Hill was an audible by Tua....So he gets points for that. Anyway, not his best game by any stretch....But 22 of 30 for 308 is still worth a B in my book.

RB's -- A : D. Achane is impressive. Period. What a homerun by Grier and McDaniel. The speed and vision he has is incredible. Give him a crease and it's a boat race. I expected him to be good.... But not this good. Add another 151 yards to his already gaudy numbers. Amazing. Mostert has revived his career at 31 and is now a top 10 RB in the NFL. 10 rushes for 65 yards yesterday for an impressive 6.5 yard per carry average is awesome. These guys got an A without question.

TE's -- B + : No TE caught a ball yesterday. Not one. They still get a B + for their inline and downfield blocking for everyone else. A nice quiet day for these guys.

WR's -- A : Hill is such a difference maker. It's crazy how fast he is. He took back the NFL Fastest man stat from Devon Achane and hit the vaunted 22 MPH mark. He would actually get ticketed in a school zone. Scary. Waddle was targeted 10 times yesterday with 5 catches and a TD. Also, Berrios had a great day....He had 2 catches for 13 yards and also caught that Instagram model as his new GF. When I die, I want to come back as his penis. Anyway...Good day all around for this group.

OL -- A - : Anyday you put up 524 total yards, your OL is doing something right. What's particularly impressive to me is the play of Austin Jackson. I've spent the last few years ripping this guy. Rightfully so. BUT... Now he's playing some really good football. I'm actually impressed and to be honest...Shocked. Connor Williams can't snap to save his ****ing life... But he an anchor a pocket with the best of them. It was nice to see him back yesterday.

DL -- A : 4 sacks from a DL is gold. 2 by the always underrated Sieler and 1.5 from Ogbah is awesome. Wilkins added another .5. Nice to see. 29 rushes for 89 yards by the G Men is a 2.93 yards per rush average. Admittedly, The Giants had to pull 2 linemen out of the stands before the game due to injuries... But we still dominated.

LB's -- A : Van Ginko and Baker combined for 2.5 sacks. Nice. Van Ginko is a terror out there lately. Nice to have him as a backup to Phillips. Regardless, a much better game than last week by these guys. albeit, against a way lesser opponent.

DB's -- A - : Allowing only 205 yards is a good game in anyone's book. The DB's were active and generally good all day... So, they get the A here. However, one thing I'll never understand is playing 10 yards off a receiver on 3rd and 9. It makes no sense to me.... But that has to be coaching.

ST's -- B - : Sanders made his kicks yesterday. I wish I could say the same thing about Bailey. The 20 yard punt wasn't good. He did come back and hit a 49 yarder though. Solid day otherwise.

Coaching -- A : The all running back drive after Tua's 2nd interception was a thing of beauty. Brilliant play calling all day by McDaniel. The Defense had pressure and Fangio called a good game with the occasional blitz coming. A good day for the coaches.

Conclusion: A good day at Hard Rock yesterday. We beat a team we should have beat. We have another one coming up this Sunday. I'd like to see Tua not make the mistakes next week and us put up about 40 points. But maybe I'm getting greedy.
 
Last edited:
Wanna know what's scary? Tua was off yesterday, and we still hung 31 points and a 500 + yards on another NFL team. That's scarier than my ex-girlfriend waking up in the morning without her makeup on. Obviously, it was a game we should have won.... And we did. But...What I really liked is how we won it anyway we needed to. Also, it's nice to see the Bills lose and put us all alone in first again. On to the grades:

QB -- B : As I mentioned earlier, Tua was off yesterday. The pick-6 was a really bad decision. As a matter of fact... there were 3 defenders around Waddle when he threw that ball. If we were playing a good team....That might have cost us the game. The other pick, I think Tua tried to stop the throw midway through his motion, but it was too late. The long bomb to Hill was an audible by Tua....So he gets points for that. Anyway, not his best game by any stretch....But 22 of 30 for 308 is still worth a B in my book.

RB's -- A : D. Achane is impressive. Period. What a homerun by Grier and McDaniel. The speed and vision he has is incredible. Give him a crease and it's a boat race. I expected him to be good.... But not this good. Add another 151 yards to his already gaudy numbers. Amazing. Mostert has revived his career at 31 and is now a top 10 RB in the NFL. !0 rushes for 65 yards yesterday for an impressive 6.5 yard per carry average is awesome. These guys got an A without question.

TE's -- B + : No TE caught a ball yesterday. Not one. They still get a B + for their inline and downfield blocking for everyone else. A nice quiet day for these guys.

WR's -- A : Hill is such a difference maker. It's crazy how fast he is. He took back the NFL Fastest man stat from Devon Achane and hit the vaunted 22 MPH mark. He would actually get ticketed in a school zone. Scary. Waddle was targeted 10 times yesterday with 5 catches and a TD. Also, Berrios had a great day....He had 2 catches for 13 yards and also caught that Instagram model as his new GF. When I die, I want to come back as his penis. Anyway...Good day all around for this group.

OL -- A - : Anyday you put up 524 total yards, your OL is doing something right. What's particularly impressive to me is the play of Austin Jackson. I've spent the last few years ripping this guy. Rightfully so. BUT... Now he's playing some really good football. I'm actually impressed and to be honest...Shocked. Connor Williams can't snap to save his ****ing life... But he an anchor a pocket with the best of them. It was nice to see him back yesterday.

DL -- A : 4 sacks from a DL is gold. 2 by the always underrated Sieler and 1.5 from Ogbah is awesome. Wilkins added another .5. Nice to see. 29 rushes for 89 yards by the G Men is a 2.93 yards per rush average. Admittedly, The Giants had to pull 2 linemen out of the stands before the game due to injuries... But we still dominated.

LB's -- A : Van Ginko and Baker combined for 2.5 sacks. Nice. Van Ginko is a terror out there lately. Nice to have him as a backup to Phillips. Regardless, a much better game than last week by these guys. albeit, against a way lesser opponent.

DB's -- A - : Allowing only 205 yards is a good game in anyone's book. The DB's were active and generally good all day... So, they get the A here. However, one thing I'll never understand is playing 10 yards off a receiver on 3rd and 9. It makes no sense to me.... But that has to be coaching.

ST's -- B - : Sanders made his kicks yesterday. I wish I could say the same thing about Bailey. The 20 yard punt wasn't good. He did come back and hit a 49 yarder though. Solid day otherwise.

Coaching -- A : The all running back drive after Tua's 2nd interception was a thing of beauty. Brilliant play calling all day by McDaniel. The Defense had pressure and Fangio called a good game with the occasional blitz coming. A good day for the coaches.

Conclusion: A good day at Hard Rock yesterday. We beat a team we should have beat. we have another one coming up this Sunday. I'd like to see Tua not make the mistakes next week and us put up about 40 points. But maybe I'm getting greedy.
Well written. Yes. To have a middling day on offense and still put up 524 yds and 31 points is nuts.
 
awesome - look forward to this every week - much appreciated! Yesterday was kind of a weird game to me - didn't seem they had their A game and yet won 31-16 - I'm not use to that as a Fins fan! Certainly nice to have that! I think Waddle is going to have to continually get more and more involved - as they tried to do this week - in order for this O to be top notch against top D's....
 
I still need to pinch myself when thinking about our Oline. What an amazing rebirth for a unit that before this year looked like a dumpster fire. Lamm and Wynn have made such an impact and gotta take my hat off for Austin Jackson, hes saved his career in his contract year.

Amazing day for the Oline once again, I love it
 
Wanna know what's scary? Tua was off yesterday, and we still hung 31 points and a 500 + yards on another NFL team. That's scarier than my ex-girlfriend waking up in the morning without her makeup on. Obviously, it was a game we should have won.... And we did. But...What I really liked is how we won it anyway we needed to. Also, it's nice to see the Bills lose and put us all alone in first again. On to the grades:

QB -- B : As I mentioned earlier, Tua was off yesterday. The pick-6 was a really bad decision. As a matter of fact... there were 3 defenders around Waddle when he threw that ball. If we were playing a good team....That might have cost us the game. The other pick, I think Tua tried to stop the throw midway through his motion, but it was too late. The long bomb to Hill was an audible by Tua....So he gets points for that. Anyway, not his best game by any stretch....But 22 of 30 for 308 is still worth a B in my book.

RB's -- A : D. Achane is impressive. Period. What a homerun by Grier and McDaniel. The speed and vision he has is incredible. Give him a crease and it's a boat race. I expected him to be good.... But not this good. Add another 151 yards to his already gaudy numbers. Amazing. Mostert has revived his career at 31 and is now a top 10 RB in the NFL. !0 rushes for 65 yards yesterday for an impressive 6.5 yard per carry average is awesome. These guys got an A without question.

TE's -- B + : No TE caught a ball yesterday. Not one. They still get a B + for their inline and downfield blocking for everyone else. A nice quiet day for these guys.

WR's -- A : Hill is such a difference maker. It's crazy how fast he is. He took back the NFL Fastest man stat from Devon Achane and hit the vaunted 22 MPH mark. He would actually get ticketed in a school zone. Scary. Waddle was targeted 10 times yesterday with 5 catches and a TD. Also, Berrios had a great day....He had 2 catches for 13 yards and also caught that Instagram model as his new GF. When I die, I want to come back as his penis. Anyway...Good day all around for this group.

OL -- A - : Anyday you put up 524 total yards, your OL is doing something right. What's particularly impressive to me is the play of Austin Jackson. I've spent the last few years ripping this guy. Rightfully so. BUT... Now he's playing some really good football. I'm actually impressed and to be honest...Shocked. Connor Williams can't snap to save his ****ing life... But he an anchor a pocket with the best of them. It was nice to see him back yesterday.

DL -- A : 4 sacks from a DL is gold. 2 by the always underrated Sieler and 1.5 from Ogbah is awesome. Wilkins added another .5. Nice to see. 29 rushes for 89 yards by the G Men is a 2.93 yards per rush average. Admittedly, The Giants had to pull 2 linemen out of the stands before the game due to injuries... But we still dominated.

LB's -- A : Van Ginko and Baker combined for 2.5 sacks. Nice. Van Ginko is a terror out there lately. Nice to have him as a backup to Phillips. Regardless, a much better game than last week by these guys. albeit, against a way lesser opponent.

DB's -- A - : Allowing only 205 yards is a good game in anyone's book. The DB's were active and generally good all day... So, they get the A here. However, one thing I'll never understand is playing 10 yards off a receiver on 3rd and 9. It makes no sense to me.... But that has to be coaching.

ST's -- B - : Sanders made his kicks yesterday. I wish I could say the same thing about Bailey. The 20 yard punt wasn't good. He did come back and hit a 49 yarder though. Solid day otherwise.

Coaching -- A : The all running back drive after Tua's 2nd interception was a thing of beauty. Brilliant play calling all day by McDaniel. The Defense had pressure and Fangio called a good game with the occasional blitz coming. A good day for the coaches.

Conclusion: A good day at Hard Rock yesterday. We beat a team we should have beat. we have another one coming up this Sunday. I'd like to see Tua not make the mistakes next week and us put up about 40 points. But maybe I'm getting greedy.

TBF, TEs weren't targeted, thus, no receptions.
A lot of tackles by the back half.
NYG quite a few big runs in the 1st series or two. After that the D was pretty good.
Overall, agree with he D.
Sloppy ball handling, TT still throwing jump balls to a 5'10" receiver, Mcd still has the occasional too-smart-for-his-own-good play calls.
RBs - need a grade higher than 'A'
Overall, I saw fewer mental errors and better tackling.
 
Second pick wasn't Tua's fault. He hit his hand. The first one was all him and he needs to (and will) obviously push himself to further refine his decision making.

Next week is the dress rehearsal for both Eagles and Chiefs. We need to look even better. With that said, we looked great and it was a tolerable day for the offense comparatively speaking vs. the other games.

What a time to be a Phins fan.
 
Thanks, Zim.

Absolutely loved the all running drive. I believe it was 75 yards and Miami just absolutely blew the Giants off the line of scrimmage.

Agree, Jackson is playing really well. Have to credit Barry here as the offensive line has been fantastic through five games.

It's pretty amazing that the Dolphins lost the turnover battle 3-0 and won easily. Get rid of those mistakes and the game might have been 41-6 or something along those lines.
 
I don't think Tua was off he just pressed hard on that one throw to Waddle in the endzone and got his arm bumped on the other, Tua was 22/30 306 yards 2 TD's 2 Int's had a nice bomb to Hill. Passing game seems to have taken a step back with the emergence of the run game.

Tua may get a B, but we have come to expect a lot from him. Still one of the better outings from a QB week 5

Achane had a fumble but also a 76-yard TD run. 11 carries 151 and 1 TD - Achane should get B+ - looks like the best RB in the league and I'm sure McDaniel's system has a lot to do with it.

Hill gets an A for his 8 rec 181 yards and no turnovers.

Our expectation from the offense have skyrocketed.
 
I don't think Tua was off he just pressed hard on that one throw to Waddle in the endzone and got his arm bumped on the other, Tua was 22/30 306 yards 2 TD's 2 Int's had a nice bomb to Hill. Passing game seems to have taken a step back with the emergence of the run game.

Tua may get a B, but we have come to expect a lot from him. Still one of the better outings from a QB week 5

Achane had a fumble but also a 76-yard TD run. 11 carries 151 and 1 TD - Achane should get B+ - looks like the best RB in the league and I'm sure McDaniel's system has a lot to do with it.

Hill gets an A for his 8 rec 181 yards and no turnovers.

Our expectation from the offense have skyrocketed.

I don’t think as a fan base who loves Tuas game we’re talking enough about how he executed the short game yesterday

It was incredibly precise.

Tua’s ability to gauge and measure the speed of his weapons is something that is never talked about but takes great talent to execute.

All folks want to talk about is the deal ball which he’s already great at
 
Smythe and Hill have been great even if they do nothing in the passing game. The actions where they get to go in motion and serve as the lead blocker are just fantastic. As much as I liked Gesicki the person getting him off the field opened up so many more things for McDaniel in the running game.
 
Back
Top Bottom