AFC East All Stars (from Bills forums) | Page 6 | FinHeaven - Miami Dolphins Forums

AFC East All Stars (from Bills forums)

djfresh47 said:
No offense to Bills fan, but the original list was taken from a Bills forum and I would think that they would know that Trey Teague is being moved to tackle, and that Rex Tucker is in position to be there center.
we also belong to a bills forum and we should also know whether or not Teague is "definitely" moving. It's a possibility but nothing is concrete. If we land Shelton we won't need to move Teague.
 
Justasportsfan said:
we also belong to a bills forum and we should also know whether or not Teague is "definitely" moving. It's a possibility but nothing is concrete. If we land Shelton we won't need to move Teague.

The last speculation I heard on the Shelton/Henry deal is that Donahoe wants to also swap 2nd rd picks. From all the reports I don't think Henry is going to show up for the Bills. I'm just going by what I get from the Bills beat reporter, but I don't know what they're gonna do with Gandy or Bennie Anderson. Also Donahoe as a lame duck GM can't be a good thing, even though I personally think he's terrible.
 
djfresh47 said:
The last speculation I heard on the Shelton/Henry deal is that Donahoe wants to also swap 2nd rd picks. From all the reports I don't think Henry is going to show up for the Bills. I'm just going by what I get from the Bills beat reporter, but I don't know what they're gonna do with Gandy or Bennie Anderson. Also Donahoe as a lame duck GM can't be a good thing, even though I personally think he's terrible.
It's all speculation.

TD being a terrrible Gm is your opinion even though he's highly regarded or respected in the league. I guess you think giving up a 2nd for a 3rd qb and giving up a 4th to mve up 1 spot for a bench warmer was a great move. :lol:
 
Justasportsfan said:
It's all speculation.

TD being a terrrible Gm is your opinion even though he's highly regarded or respected in the league. I guess you think giving up a 2nd for a 3rd qb and giving up a 4th to mve up 1 spot for a bench warmer was a great move. :lol:

No Spielmen is awful also. What has Donahoe done in Buffalo? I like the Losman move, but that's about it. Gregg Williams are you kidding me? Mularkey did a decent job last year, but he signed a 5 yr contract, and I believe was hired more because of the fact that he's Donahoe's "boy" from Pitt rather than a better candidate than Crennel or Weis was. Mike Williams was a horrible pick, he started playing decently under Jim McNally but he's been a bust IMO. I always go back to this but were the Bills a good enough team at the time to draft Willis McGahee when they had a proven RB? McGahee is a better RB than Henry but I don't think he was good enough to be taken in the 1st rd when they had Henry. Also how many D-ends he drafts are labeled the "next Phil Hansen," Justin Bannan was such a great DT prospect that they moved him to guard? Tom Donahoe has had too much time in Buffalo and has not done nearly enough, I as a Dolphan hope they give him more time but, if they do not re-sign him what happens to Mularkey and that 5 yr deal that he signed? Spielmen is awful, but Donahoe also overpaid over paid for Bledsoe when no other team was willing to give up a 1st rd pick for him.
 
djfresh47 said:
No Spielmen is awful also. What has Donahoe done in Buffalo? I like the Losman move, but that's about it. Gregg Williams are you kidding me? Mularkey did a decent job last year, but he signed a 5 yr contract, and I believe was hired more because of the fact that he's Donahoe's "boy" from Pitt rather than a better candidate than Crennel or Weis was. Mike Williams was a horrible pick, he started playing decently under Jim McNally but he's been a bust IMO. I always go back to this but were the Bills a good enough team at the time to draft Willis McGahee when they had a proven RB? McGahee is a better RB than Henry but I don't think he was good enough to be taken in the 1st rd when they had Henry. Also how many D-ends he drafts are labeled the "next Phil Hansen," Justin Bannan was such a great DT prospect that they moved him to guard? Tom Donahoe has had too much time in Buffalo and has not done nearly enough, I as a Dolphan hope they give him more time but, if they do not re-sign him what happens to Mularkey and that 5 yr deal that he signed? Spielmen is awful, but Donahoe also overpaid over paid for Bledsoe when no other team was willing to give up a 1st rd pick for him.
His boy from Pitts? Boy are you clueless. They hardly knew each other. Mularkey was barely the TE coach when TD left. Get your facts straight.

You like to talk about the Willis move. Who was there at 23 in that weak draft that could've started over any of our starters then No one could answer that back then and no one can now. Since you hardly had any foresight then (obviously based on your comments about that draft) , TD was right and you were wrong. We can barley get anything for Henry now.

It's easy to be a forum GM. Even then ,you are awful at it. Even when there are facts right infront of you, you still think he's done badly. I will admit Greghead and Drew were mistakes. Considering the situation we were in w/ Robosack, Drew was the best available qb then. Hellooo.

You criticize him for the Willis move and praise him for the Losman move even though he has yet to prove himself? :huh:


BTW, what is your opinion on Saban as a GM? Is he better than TD?
 
Justasportsfan said:
:lol: Based on what? A 0-0 record?

Guess What Nick and TB have in common ? They both have yet to make the playoffs. And that's with a three year head start for TD.. :lol: :lol:
 
Mularkey is third, Saban hasn't coached a game.

Losman is fourth, he hasn't started a game yet.



Moulds is definatly the best, he always shows it. If Moulds drops it will be to Evans.



I'll give the nod to Zach.





Clements played better than Surtain and Madison last year.



Is this list based on last years performance?
 
armyfinfan said:
If Moulds drops it will be to Chambers.

i think moulds's numbers will be limited by JP.
but i also think chambers numbers will be limited by AJ.

chambers has yet to have a 1000 yard season, and has NEVER caught more than 69 passes.

Chambers is good. dont get me wrong... but i dont see him in the probowl any time soon.
 
How does Tedy Bruischi get in last? Even though he had a stroke. It should be
Bruschi-Thomas-Flecther-Vilma

P.S. I hate to say it but, Bruschi is better than Thomas.
 
ch19079 said:
i think moulds's numbers will be limited by JP.
but i also think chambers numbers will be limited by AJ.

chambers has yet to have a 1000 yard season, and has NEVER caught more than 69 passes.

Chambers is good. dont get me wrong... but i dont see him in the probowl any time soon.
I think Moulds could get better w/ JP. Moulds was his best w/ Flutie throwing to him. Flutie took chances by throwing it up and allowing to let Moulds come down w/ it which is Moulds' best attribute. Maybe JP will trust Moulds to make plays here and there.

Drew was scared to take chances which is why he got sacked a lot.
 
ch19079 said:
a quick list of errors:
D. Branch above Moulds??? as the #1???? WOW.
Clements above madison
Coles is better than chambers. (whats the most receptons hes ever gotten in a season??)
saban should be last on the list, for the same reason JP is last behind AJ. (but MM did a very good job last year)
and i hate the bills kicker so much, i think our team would be better off without a kicker. if we dont get to the 30 we will punt anyways.

for once i agree with a Jills fan except the saban thing
 
Back
Top Bottom