AJ Feeley one of the worst 20 qb performances of all time? | Page 2 | FinHeaven - Miami Dolphins Forums

AJ Feeley one of the worst 20 qb performances of all time?

where's the top 20 worst offensive line performances of all time? 2004 could top that list easily
 
Thebignate5 said:
don't know if this has been posted before but...



http://sports.espn.go.com/espn/page2/story?page=schatz/050812&num=3


THE NEXT 10
11. Kerry Collins, 1997 Carolina Panthers
12. Steve DeBerg, 1978 San Francisco 49ers
13. John McCormick, 1966 Denver Broncos
14. Rusty Hilger, 1988 Detroit Lions
15. Archie Manning, 1975 New Orleans Saints
16. Jack Trudeau, 1986 Indianapolis Colts
17. Ryan Leaf, 2000 San Diego Chargers
18. Boomer Esiason, 1992 Cincinnati Bengals
19. A.J. Feeley, 2004 Miami Dolphins
20. Terry Bradshaw, 1970 Pittsburgh Steelers

Funny, I've been around long enough to remember most of those teams...guess what...they were terrible teams...every single one of them...not just the QB, not just the OL the entire team and coaches were terrible...if you are trying to show something about Feeley and this list...save it...this is a team sport and the entire team stunk, not just the QB...
 
lets be realistic...

for 05/06 - go Gus

for the future - go our new rookie.


AJs not a bum. but he's NOT our QB of the future. i don't know about all of you, but i want a star. someone who can win a game almost on his own, not someone who can hold shop. AJ isn't much of an upgrade over Fiedler, who will be proved over the next few years to have done a serviceable job - not world-beating but not bad. i don't see AJ doing any better.

and if i'm wrong, i'll eat my humble pie with cream. but be honest, i'm not wrong.
 
I wasn't trying to bash Feeley, I'm actually a Feeley supporter....I'm just trying to show ypu guys something from national coverage that I don't think anyone has posted and see if you agree with it or not. You all jumped on me like I'm just trying to start a flame AJ thread...I'm not. I like AJ.
 
Thebignate5 said:
don't know if this has been posted before but...



http://sports.espn.go.com/espn/page2/story?page=schatz/050812&num=3


THE NEXT 10
11. Kerry Collins, 1997 Carolina Panthers
12. Steve DeBerg, 1978 San Francisco 49ers
13. John McCormick, 1966 Denver Broncos
14. Rusty Hilger, 1988 Detroit Lions
15. Archie Manning, 1975 New Orleans Saints
16. Jack Trudeau, 1986 Indianapolis Colts
17. Ryan Leaf, 2000 San Diego Chargers
18. Boomer Esiason, 1992 Cincinnati Bengals
19. A.J. Feeley, 2004 Miami Dolphins
20. Terry Bradshaw, 1970 Pittsburgh Steelers
What's your point? out of that list I see... 3 guys who started a super bowl.
 
I'm just showing something I thought was interesting, christ you guys are insane
 
Thebignate5 said:
I'm just showing something I thought was interesting, christ you guys are insane
you're right it is interesting, but are you making an arguement for or against Feeley? Because looking at those guys on the list, you could go either way.
 
I'm not making an argument for EITHER lol, that's what you guys are supposed to do, discuss it, if they agree with it or not and what they think about it...I just thought it would make for good discussion and instead everyone jumps on me :(
 
kastofsna120 said:
where's the top 20 worst offensive line performances of all time? 2004 could top that list easily

It wasn't even the worst in the league last year.
 
Man I just don't know, I saw Feeley light it up when he was a back-up in Philly on occasions...I'd like to believe that the ''powers that be'' in the Dolphins organization know what their doing when they sought a player like Feeley, I've been a supporter of his for quite some time. BUT, and this is a huge but, it appears Feeley is....well....about as much an NFL QB as my brother-in-law. Now it could be hes in a coaching change funk, or a too many expectations on me funk, but id swear its a....trade me for a 2nd string right tackle fast funk. Im thinkin Feeley is done, call me a reverse homer but he's a no talent bum who you could'nt count on to pass a note in class. I'm not even sure a vet QB would fix the offense, only thing I am sure of is the O coordinator should'nt sign any long term commitments just yet.:refuse:
 
Thebignate5 said:
don't know if this has been posted before but...



http://sports.espn.go.com/espn/page2/story?page=schatz/050812&num=3


THE NEXT 10
11. Kerry Collins, 1997 Carolina Panthers
12. Steve DeBerg, 1978 San Francisco 49ers
13. John McCormick, 1966 Denver Broncos
14. Rusty Hilger, 1988 Detroit Lions
15. Archie Manning, 1975 New Orleans Saints
16. Jack Trudeau, 1986 Indianapolis Colts
17. Ryan Leaf, 2000 San Diego Chargers
18. Boomer Esiason, 1992 Cincinnati Bengals
19. A.J. Feeley, 2004 Miami Dolphins
20. Terry Bradshaw, 1970 Pittsburgh Steelers

EDIT: I AM NOT TRYING TO BASH FEELEY. I am not making an argument against Feeley or for him. I am asking for ya'll to discuss whether first if you agree with it or not and just in general if he belongs on that list...I also just thought it was interesting and wanted to see if you guys would read it.

When is Vick going to be in that list?
 
Back
Top Bottom