All-time favorite non-Dolphin?

[traptses]

Ray Lewis and Marshawn Lynch

 

[sickdawg]

Without a doubt Barry Sanders. On defense it would be Lawrence Taylor.....he absolutely TERRORIZED his opponents like no one else

 

[Fin-Loco]

Peyton Manning

 

[hab321]

I'd have to say Sweetness, followed by Barry Sanders

 

[dolphindan]

Steve McNair

 

[KTDolphins]

Tony Romo, dude is a way better commentator than he was a player, and regularly gives the fins props.

 

[Fin-Loco]

If anyone says Tom Brady or Boomer Esiason they should have their knee caps drilled while being forced to watch The Schmenges...

 

[OmegaPhinsFan]

Peyton Manning

Tom Brady

 

[Fin-Loco]

Tom Brady

 

[joeylats]

Mike Alstott

 

[Andyman]

Lawrence Taylor and Eric Dickerson

 

[coalesce]

I’m glad someone else mentioned Mean Joe Greene. He and the rest of the Steel Curtain absolutely manhandled Earl Campbell, something the Dolphins could never do.

 

[packfin]

Barry Sanders... Fantasy Football - so silly?

 

[The Bopkin]

Wow, what a tough question.
How about, as a kid: Fran Tarkenton
As an adult, Larry Fitzgerald.
Is that cheating?

 

[raving]

Earl the freight train Campbell....
Walter Peyton
Joe Montana
Lawrence Taylor
Jerry Rice
Fred Belitnekoff
Lynn Swann
Jack Lambert
Mike singletary
Lamar Jackson