Ok, I gotta chime in.
IMO, Ogden's the odd man out. So it's between Baker and A.J. And because we're talking about the 5th WR spot here......you can't say that Baker has outperformed A.J. because the 5th WR has to be a special teamer.
And as far as special teams go, A.J. is the man. Baker has certainly been the better WR. He can make things happen. But there's four other guys ahead of him. And they're going to get ALL the time. So Baker's WR skills would go to waste while A.J. would be performing his specialty.....returning kicks.
It hurts me to say this, but I gotta go with A.J. Johnson. Baker has been my guy since 1999. I saw him blow out his knee when he was tearing up training camp. I've watched him fight every year. I really, really, really wanted him to make it. And he will catch on somewhere. But A.J. is the game breaking return man that we've lacked for I don't know how many years.
IMO, Ogden's the odd man out. So it's between Baker and A.J. And because we're talking about the 5th WR spot here......you can't say that Baker has outperformed A.J. because the 5th WR has to be a special teamer.
And as far as special teams go, A.J. is the man. Baker has certainly been the better WR. He can make things happen. But there's four other guys ahead of him. And they're going to get ALL the time. So Baker's WR skills would go to waste while A.J. would be performing his specialty.....returning kicks.
It hurts me to say this, but I gotta go with A.J. Johnson. Baker has been my guy since 1999. I saw him blow out his knee when he was tearing up training camp. I've watched him fight every year. I really, really, really wanted him to make it. And he will catch on somewhere. But A.J. is the game breaking return man that we've lacked for I don't know how many years.