Best Miami QB since Marino?

[Whitedolphin54]

In watching both guy's play I would have to say Wingnut as he made up with his inconsistent performances by showing better leadership and awareness

 

[QB2RonnieTD23]

no votes for Ray Lucas then? :)

 

[Dolphins84]

no way is it Jay. it's Griese.... Brian can perform at a probowl level. Jay Fiedler was lucky to ever throw for 200 yards in a game.

that doenst answer the question at all because it was who was the best on the dolphins since marino and griese did terrible for us when Jay led us to the playoffs 3 times and had a great record. Fiedler is the obvious answer.

 

[Oregonfinfan]

I hate to break it to you all I to wanted bree's in here but lets not kid ourselves if he played as bad here as he did there unitl now we would have trash canned his rear and had to draft a qb just like they have so just because now he is playing good he really was a turd for quite a while!

 

[Regan21286]

that doenst answer the question at all because it was who was the best on the dolphins since marino and griese did terrible for us when Jay led us to the playoffs 3 times and had a great record. Fiedler is the obvious answer.

Jay didn't lead us to the playoffs 3 times, only 2. Plus, he rode the coattails of an outstanding defense much like Trent Dilfer did. When it came time to play against a D that concentrated on the run like the Oakland playoff or Baltimore playoff game, Jay was exposed.