Best QB of all time...

[DolFan74]

Here's a hypothetical situation. Give me your answer.
There's two teams

One QB throws for 200 yards 2 tds and 1 int

the other QB throws for 300 yards 3 tds and 1 int

QB #1s team ran for 150 yards
QB #2s team ran for 45 yards

QB #1 team's Defense is the best in the league
QB #2 team's defense is the worst in the league

The score was 35-28 in favor of QB #1s team

Who was the better QB.

#2 had more yards and TD's So he would be for that 1 game..even tho his team lost.

 

[fish920]

in a HUGE miami fan but i have to go with montana.... sorry dan :dolphins:

 

[Straztheman]

in a HUGE miami fan but i have to go with montana.... sorry dan :dolphins:

montanas teams where always stacked i cant stand it when people tell me that montana is better than marino you put marino on montanas 49ers teams marino would have won a super bowl every year.

 

[Straztheman]

Dan Marino look at the stats.

 

[Dolfan984]

in a HUGE miami fan but i have to go with montana.... sorry dan :dolphins:

Bro, the 49ers defense was SICK in the 80s. You ever watch the Dolphins 49ers Superbowl from 1985? Marino had one good drive against them, Walsh figured it out and then just overwhelmed the whole team while they ran the ball down our small defensive linemens' throats.

 

[Amars]

Elway.

 

[DolFan74]

Though my favorite is Dan the Man of course and a close 2nd is Joe Montana,I see that Warren Moon wasnt on the list..How is that possible?,the dude threw for 49325 yards in just his NFL Career..Just think of the yardage he would have thrown for if he had played his entire career in the NFL and not 5 or 6 in the CFL.

 

[OJMcDuffie]

As if there is any choice but one: Dan the man.