Best QB of all time

[nyjunc]

The big thing about 2007 did they win when it matered and the awnser to that is no, im not saying that brady isnt the best QB of all time because i believe he is top 3 of the all time great QB my top three would be Mixed between Joe Montana, Tom Brady, and Peyton Manning. probably in that order

Peyton has come up small in too many big spots to be top 5.

 

[FootballCEO]

Marino, Montana, Elway, Moon, Esiason! Just my own personal list...

 

[nyjunc]

Marino, Montana, Elway, Moon, Esiason! Just my own personal list...

Boomer? He was agreat for stretch but not long enough to be up there w/ Montana, marino and Elway.

Moon was a fantasy guy, great regs eason #s in the run and shoot but he was terrible when it mattered.

 

[BARF]

again with a thread like this, how many times have we done this