Actually, if you go back and figure out who'd have made the playoffs if there were seven teams advancing in each conference every year, several of them might have.
As it is, Wannstedt did it. He was 41-23 through four years. JJ made the playoffs three straight years after missing his first year by going 8-8 -- Jimmy Johnson never had a sub-.500 record in Miami.
People seem to be remembering things a lot worse than they were. Several of these guys felt heat for just winning 10 games and losing in the opening round of the playoffs because everyone compared them to Don Shula. Sparano and Gase both won double-digit games and made the playoffs their first year in 16-game seasons.
The thing is in almost every one of those cases they never got better. That's why I have a problem when anyone says next year it'll be better. It might not be. Many of our coaches since Shula either came out of the gates really good or looked really good in their second year and got stuck at that level. They felt pressure from the fanbase, panicked, lost the team and went into a death spiral and either quit or got fired.
That's what I say that even with McDaniel, we've seen this before. The only difference is now it's been so many years since Shula that instead of expecting us to contend for Super Bowls all the time, now the fans accept being decent -- they've lost the ambition to demand the Dolphins be better than this because they've seen how bad it can get when we expect more.